Guessing the half dime or the half dollar. Hmmm... I'll guess that the half dollar didn't make it, all nice coins though, and nothing jumps out as misgraded.
I'll stick to my original guess that it is either the Half Dime or the 2C with the 2C being the one that didn't. I feel like it may have been a surprise one given the creation of the tread though.
The AU 1838 Half dime. Should not have "beaned" the low eye appeal XF-40 Seated half either. Just my opinion.
No, the AU-58 1838 Half dime. That's why I don't have a chance at GTG tests. If were a TPGS finalizer, the 1838 would get MS-62 at the Max! The VF-35, 1840 50c would get XF-40 as it is a dog as far as eye-appeal. I agree with the grade of the next three coins. BTW, years ago "blue" copper was considered artificial color at the TPGS! Wish they were mine so I could "improve" a few of them.
Maybe it's my pics. It's actually a very nice half dollar the 1840/1840 none the less. NGC population of 2.