You didn't have a transaction. You had to cancel the sale to send a Second Chance. Why/how would/could he leave Feedback?
I believe that if you cancel the sale, it prevents him from leaving feedback. I'd check with eBay before doing so . . .
What a con artist. Even if it had been "improperly cleaned" that coin is worth a whole lot more than $14. He wants to get it graded and slabbed.
Time did not afford him the ability to look at what he was going to spend his money on? You got off lucky, man. This guy is gonna be a nightmare to someone, down the road.
Block him. I would love to buy a few cleaned key coins at melt. I might start using his argument, you never know what kinda deals you might get! haha
I am curious. Not a bad picture. What do some of the sharp eyes around here give to that coin as a grade?
Yup. Should be $75-ish at retail. It's on the "good" side for a cleaned coin, having few marks or other distractions.