GTG: 1883 CC Morgan

This one will be fun:

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

65 - Nice die crack stringing the letters STATES OF together.

 

I'll go 64 . Nice coin .

 

65

 

64

 

Since its in a numistrust holder, I'll go with ms66
Does anyone actually trust numistrust?
Nice Morgan btw

 

64

 

Oh man, I even tried to crop the photo. You got it. The coin looked real nice and the price was real low so I thought I'd take a gamble.What are the chances this would crossover to a 65 at PCGS? Would my chances be better submitting raw?

 

This is a toughie.....
It has a shot at 65 but I believe you will need to send it raw. It will no doubt go 64 64+ or 65, but maybe you could do a poll and see what the community thinks on that one?

 

The way my grades have been going It'll probably get a 63. But I guess I'll be cracking my first holder open. If it got a 64 I would probably break even.

 

Judging by your other GtG Morgan, maybe you should send it to NGC

 

The concept of crossover for this coin is meaningless. It's equivalent to putting a coin in a 2x2, writing MS66 on it, and wondering if it'll "cross." It is currently a raw coin stuck in a holder. Break it out and submit it for grading if you want it graded. Looks like a 64.

 

Looks like it will grade a 64+, it's rare for them to give out plus grades so it will either be MS-64 or MS-65 if you are very lucky.

I think it is very unlikely for it to grade MS-66 in a PCGS or NGC slab.

 

Crack it and send it. It's a solid 64. And worth more in a pcgs or ngc 64 holder then in a new mistrust 66 holder I'd maybe try for a bean after too

 

I think it's a 64 all day long. You'd be better off cracking it out and submitting it.

 

64

 

Why crack it out? It is probably a 64 (definitely NOT a 66). The price difference between a 63 and 64 in that date isn't significant. No way it is a 66 and unlikely a 65. The big jump is in the 66 grade, and no way PCGS or NGC grades that coin as 66.

 

Good point. Although, sometimes, for new collectors of a series, buying, cracking and submitting is a good way to learn to grade. It's real life experience.

 

Cause nobody serious would ever look at it in the slab its in. Is better raw even then you can at least make your own decision on grade not the bs 66 they call it. I wonder what new mistrust would call a real 66. Ms 72?

 

Because it's in a toxic slab.