GTG: First time PCGS Grading Part 2

Here's a couple more: 1879 S Morgan and 64 D Kennedy:

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

That Morgan is really beat up! It's got nice luster, but it's really beat up! I'm guessing (assuming no details grade) an MS61 or an AU53.

The Kennedy, I'm guessing a 62-63?

 

I was thinking more '63 on the Morgan......got's a feeling it's more of the angle on the photo, showing up more 'chatter' than what would be perceived in hand. '64 on the Kennedy.......

 

62 and 63

 

62
64

 

63/64?

 

62 and 64.

 

Ms63 on the morgan, ms65 on the kennedy

 

63
65

Sort of perplexed why you submitted the Kennedy?

 

jwitten and physics fan guessed it. The reason I submitted the Kennedy is pretty much in the title. I'm new to this and was thinking it would get a 66, but now I know that was never going to happen. What's interesting is this Morgan got a 63 and the 1900-s got a 62, but to my eyes the 62 looked way better.

 

I gotta be honest... I looked up the results since you posted your other coins already with the submission numbers.... hehe

 

Lol, I didn't even know you could do that. It shows every coin from my submission?

Edit: I see what you did. You just incremented (or decremented) the cert number!

 

My guess was 64-Morgan, 62Kennedy. Kinda surprised

 

Compare the luster on this Morgan to the other one. This one is far more lustrous. Also, compare the amount of fine tickmarks, scrapes, and dings on this one to the other one - this one is much cleaner.

 

I agree about the luster, but I'm just not seeing it on the surface preservation.