I got this at a low price and of course it makes you wonder. I checked the date against a known authentic example and looks good to me. What do you think? Look OK? I know it is low grade, G Details but still kind of cheap. http://www.ebay.com/itm/1909-O-Barb...DADQQ%2BWWxff8jehpxwc%3D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc
Right, I had to check it out first since I won it for a little over $7 with shipping. Most guides I checked have it at $40-$58. I know that guides don't mean much but when you get it for like 10-20% of it, need to just give a check.
I'd probably call it AG-3. It's hard to tell if its been cleaned in those photos, but it most likely has. I'd say you got a good deal - its probably worth more like $10 or $15 (retail).
I am trying to figure out if this coin is actually a 1909-D. The mint mark looks a lot like a D. I posted another thread about it.