Only keeping 1 (poll)

They are all beautiful

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Having seen them in hand, the mark on #1 is simply a streak in the toning. The luster on #2 has more boom than #1, but less rainbow. I'd have a hard time choosing between them.

 

Thanks messydesk for the photos!

 

#1 would be my first choice. It has the best strike and really nice toning.
#4 would be my second choice. Still nice color and looks like great luster.

 

Since the mark isn't a surface defect, I'd pick #1, with #2 a very close second.

 

Yes I agree 1 And 2 are to me the best eye appeal . The 38 D needs to be looked at for the rpm. But to pick one I would go with #1

 

Add me to the #2 list

 

I like #2, although #4 is a real honey, too.

 

The type 1 is closest to the artist's vision and #2 is a better strike

 

#2 calls to me the most out of 1 & 2. 3 & 4 are 3rd and 4th place for me.

The 13-ty2 has a weak strike and too much haze in the toning and the 38-D is fair 'common'.

 

#2 It has the best strike and luster plus some cool color, especially on the back. I also feel it is under graded and belongs in a 65 holder.

 

That's a good point, neither do I see what's holding #2 out of gem.

 

Can't pick #1 because of the scratch. #2 is very nice.

 

I picked #4, but it really depends on what your goal is. I think better struck 1913 type 1 and 2's are available. Just my opinion.

 

I like 1