1922 monster toned peace dollar

You guys have made your case and i will concede.....this census was heavily favored one way and i cant dispute the facts... see im not ALWAYS argumentative... im a pretty reasonable guy and i think those of.us that are passionate make this a really cool hobby

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

it does not look natural. sorry. ya learn as you go. God knows I have learned on a few toned coins. chalk it up as a learning experience.

 

• "AT" hands down, I've never seen a coin tone natural like that specimen,

 

Don't crack it out...

 

Good looking but not natural tomed pcgs ngc not grade it coean

 

Toning looks very unnatural to me as well.

 

It looks like Liberty has a lot of marks on her face for a 63. Hard to tell what the toning is hiding in the image. I feel PCGS or NGC would detail grade it because of the toning. With that said, I still think it's a pretty coin.

 

Yupp. It will not grade with either of the biggies--questionable color.

 

I agree with those calling it AT.

 

Paraphrasing but IIRC David Hall said something like if a peace $ is rainbow its AT.

 

And he is full of crap. It's been 50 years since he was a young collector...plenty of time for toning to occur.

 

Here is a lovely one that even CACed...

https://collectivecoin.com/coinman23885/all-coins/ZtpBplJge5zlfDg1lYQU

 

IIRC, he walked that statement back a bit after he made it. His point was that all rainbow toned Peace Dollars should be scrutinized for originality, and when in doubt, err on the side of caution.

 

just thought I would show one of mine ..

 

I highly doubt it will cross.

 

necro thread

 

If it was less than $50 I probably would have bought it. At $180, I would have passed.

 

Looking back at this thread ive armed myself with experience and knowledge since 1-15.
Definitely AT and ICG should be ashamed of themselves lol