After further research, I find that the reverse of the RI quarter was actually designed by Thomas D. Rodgers and not Daniel Carr. http://www.usmint.gov/historianscorner/?action=coindetail&id=29212
I also found that the reverse of the NY quarter was designed by Alfred Maletsky. http://www.usmint.gov/historianscorner/?action=coinDetail&id=29209
http://www.dc-coin.com/signaturestatequarters.aspx Alfred Maletsky was an engraver for the US Mint as was Thomas D. Rogers. They "engraved" the winning designs that Daniel Carr submitted during the State Quarters program. Unlike other programs, winning "designs" were selected by each States Governor then submitted to the US Mint who would then adapt the design for us on the coins. The actual "designers" initials were never used. Sometimes, the level of ignorance that invades coin forums is simply amazing.
But it seems that his main income is from using the designs that others created and he has used without explicit permission, rather than his own.
My info came from the mint's web site. Yeah, the level of ignorance is quite high here, O All Knowing Great Poobah.
They don't mention the designers on any of the state quarters, only the engravers. Dan Carr DID design the New York and Rhode Island quarters.
If you look here http://www.usmint.gov/historianscorner/?action=coindetail&id=29212 and here http://www.usmint.gov/historianscorner/?action=coinDetail&id=29209 they specifically say DESIGNER, not ENGRAVER. RI Reverse Designer: Thomas D. Rodgers NY Reverse Designer: Alfred Maletsky I would think that if DC really designed these coins, he'd have demanded a correction by now.
Maine Quarter Specifications Designers: William Cousins after John Flanagan (obverse), Daniel Carr (reverse) Composition: 91.67% copper, 8.33% nickel (clad), 90% silver, 10% copper (silver proof) Diameter: 24.26 mm Weight: 5.67 grams Thickness: 1.75 mm Edge: Reeded Rhode Island Quarter Specifications Designers: William Cousins after John Flanagan (obverse), Daniel Car (reverse) Composition: 91.67% copper, 8.33% nickel (clad), 90% silver, 10% copper (silver proof) Diameter: 24.26 mm Weight: 5.67 grams Thickness: 1.75 mm Edge: Reeded New York Quarter Specifications Designers: William Cousins after John Flanagan (obverse), Daniel Car (reverse) Composition: 91.67% copper, 8.33% nickel (clad), 90% silver, 10% copper (silver proof) Diameter: 24.26 mm Weight: 5.67 grams Thickness: 1.75 mm Edge: Reeded
Yeah, but only after he changed his designs in the manner instructed by the US Mint. His original design was not accepted.
Depends on how ya look at it. Read this, it will explain - http://www.scvhistory.com/scvhistory/signal/coins/worden-coinage1205a.htm
No, the US Mint mandated the changes. The mint always has the final word in any coin design. edit - For example, I once co-designed a token for our coin club. But when the mint (a private mint) was finally chosen to mint them the design had to be changed according to their instructions. And quite simply I, nor my co- designer (I did the obv he did the rev) had no say in the matter. It was change it or find somebody else to mint it.
Ok, same thing. The US Mint modified CARR's design. I'm sure modifications are made on a majority of designer's works, whether it is coins, buildings, etc. That doesn't take away from who's original design is modified.