Keep One, Sell Three

Which one of the four would you keep? I only want one for my type set.
The 1943 D is Pcgs MS64FB, And Thanks to Gbroke for photos.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

The 1939.

 

40 or the 43. Those two have the 'cleanest' look through the toning.

That mottled toning doesn't look as good as that smoother toning.

 

the 1939.

 

1940 all the way!

 

why sell any of them. they all are awesome.

 

I can free up money to buy something else I need for my type set.

 

1940

What is the average grade of your type set? You should keep the one that fits in best or the one that you like the most.

 

Its a toned type set. Im not really concerned with grades

 

I know I absolutely need that 40. My answer is anything but!

 

I would have kept the 1916-S MS62, just missed it.

The 1943 MS67 was a brief second choice based on slab and grade. The presentation lacks a bit with a few scratches and scuffs on the slab.

Looking purely at coin eye appeal and presentation, my vote is PCGS MS66 1940.

 

I like the anacs one and the NGC ms67 one. I would keep those two and sell the other 2

 

The 1939

 

1939

 

Have to agree! Nice looking dime with the periphery looking even and natural just like it should. The others are alright but the 40 takes the cake.

 

Since it is for your type set which is primarily toners, I would keep the '39.

Chris

 

I would keep the 1943D as an FB example. TC

 

Were it not for the dark speckles on the '39 that would be far and away the most attractive toning. The '43 D has the best strike of all of them but it doesn't quite make the grade. The '43 Philly is just butt ugly. So I went with the '40.

 

40

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk