To my way of seeing it, 'punch' should be reserved for reverses without design like the original rough punches shown on the first three coins. When you add letters and other pictorial elements, it becomes a reverse type. They may be in an incuse square or be an incuse design but they are not punches as I would use the term.
Lesbos was the home of the poet Sappho whose works became associated with 'something else' in the 19th century. What was considered normal in 600BC and what was normal in 1880 AD is rather different. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sappho
=> yah, you're right ... I guess I should have merely called the thread "archaic incuse coins" rather than "incuse punch coins" (hey, ya caught me!!)
Thrace, Chersonesos 400-350 BC AR hemidrachm, 13mm, 2.3gm Obv: forepart of a lion right, head reverted Rev: quadripartite; incuse; dot AΓ (ligate) and pentagram in opposing depressions Ref: ? Haven't found this one yet in any online resources
THRACE. Byzantion 340-320 BC AR siglos, 17 mm, 5.0 gm Obv: Heifer standing left on dolphin swimming to left Rev: Incuse mill-sail pattern Ref: SNG BM Black Sea 21 Interesting and beautiful tobacco/rose toning
ARGOLIS, Argos 330-270 BC AR Triobol or Hemidrachm, 14mm, 2.4 g Obv: forepart of wolf left, retrograde Σ above Rev: large A; Π–Ρ above, club below; all within shallow incuse square Ref: BCD Peloponnesos 1083.3; HGC 5, 667 ex Dr. Georgios I. Michael Collection current TIF Pink Floyd Animals collection, track 2, "Dogs"
ARGOLIS, Argos 330-270 BC AR Triobol or Hemidrachm, 13mm, 2.5 g Obv: forepart of wolf left Rev: Large A; triskeles below; all within shallow incuse square Ref: BCD Peloponnesos 1075.2; HGC 5, 667 ex Dr. Georgios I. Michael Collection current TIF Pink Floyd Animals collection, track 2, "Dogs"
IONIA, Samos. 510-500 BC AR drachm, 13.7 mm, 3.2 gm Obv: forepart of winged boar left Rev: facing lion scalp with dotted square, within incuse square Ref: SNG Cop 1673 current TIF Pink Floyd Animals collection; track 5, "Pigs on the Wing, Part II"
IONIA, Klazomenai 499-494 BC AR diobol, 10 mm, 1.0 gm Obv: forepart of winged boar right Rev: quadripartite incuse square, K Ref: SNG München 451 current TIF Pink Floyd Animals collection; track 1, "Pigs on the Wing, Part I"
IONIA, Klazomenai 499-494 BC AR diobol, 9mm, 1.2 g Obv: forepart of winged boar left Rev: incuse square Ref: Cf. BMC 9-10 (drachm); cf. Traité I 488 (drachm). VF, toned, porous. Very rare with boar left, apparently unpublished as a diobol ex Daniel Koppersmith Collection. Ex Classical Numismatic Group Electronic Auction 256 (25 May 2011), lot 123. current TIF Pink Floyd Animals collection, track 1, "Pigs on the Wing, Part I"
CARIA, Mylasa 450-400 BC AR hemiobol, 7 x 9 mm, 0.5 gm Obv: facing forepart of lion Rev: scorpion within incuse square Ref: SNG von Aulock 7803; Klein 429 (Milet) ------ So yeah, I've got a few incuse punch types I've got more but they're not yet loaded to my website. Sure is easier posting coins to CT from my new website, compared to digging through my hard drive and looking for the auction bookmark!
Well, I'll try not to toss-in any barnyard animal names whenever I'm referring to Your Royal Coin-Highness, okay? ... oh, but here is my far less impressive Flyin' Pig & Lion incuse (sadly, my pig certainly doesn't come-across as a real Flyin' Ace, does he?!!)
Perhaps because it's not a winged boar, just a regular terrestrial boar. And isn't the whole thing excuse in relief, rather than incuse?
=> AHA!! ... well, that certainly explains why my poor pig keeps getting injured when he jumps outta the plane with all of his winged buddies!! ... according to my notes/description, the Lion is apparently in an incuse square (sadly, my flan is a bit too tight to show the full-effect ... which I'm sure is the reasoning for me "not" posting this example way-back-when, last year)