america the beautiful 5 oz p SP70 NGC PCGS PRICE DIFFERENCE

is there anyone know
FOR EXAMPLE 2013 america the beautiful 5 oz p Mount Rushmore National Park both sp 70
the PRICE OF THE COINS in PCGS GRADING SP70 MORE THAN $100 higher than the coins in NGC grading.
I check on ebay for these kind of coin the PCGS SP70 FIRST STRIKE ONE IS ABOUT $320 ( I mean no signature one just first strike) the NGC SP70 EARLY RELEASE IS ABOUT $220 .
IS THERE ANYONE GIVE ME THE ANSWER?

ANOTHER QUESTION:
I CHECK ON NGC STATUS FOR ATB 5 OZ THE SP70 EARLY RELEASE POP
THE 2012 YOSEMITE IS 1316 AND GRAND CAYON IS 1168 BOTH OF THESE COINS POP ARE HIGHER WHY THE PRICE OF THESE COINS ARE HIGHER THE OTHER COINS. FOR NGC SP70 OVER $320?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

The market must perceive PCGS as more accurate than NGC for these pucks.

Some issues probably sell for more because of higher demand, even though their pops are higher.

 

Hype. That's all the higher price tag for these PCGS graded bullion "coins" is.

The difference between a 69 and a 70 on moderns like this is rarely discernible, and highly variable. I would put good money on that if one cracked out a"70" piece and resubmitted it to the same company, it could come back as a 69 or 70 basically at random.

 

No need to yell ;0)


Early release an first strikes IMO are nothing but marketing gimmicks.

As for the value difference IMO NGC is overall more lenient then PCGS with a few exceptions.

 

"Few" exceptions? Like basically all non-USA coins? PCGS is also more "lenient" on many designations including but not limited to FB Roosevelts, FBL Franklin halves, and FS Jefferson nickels.

With regard to the 5oz pucks, I don't think one is more lenient than the other. Sometimes I wonder if they just spin a wheel with a little arrow that points to either 69 or 70. But, then again, I don't understand why people slab stuff like this at all.

 

Just an FYI, First Strike would suggest that it was the very first coin in the series to be struck on the new dies. Since the Mint doesn't keep track of such things, it really isn't a first strike.

Secondly, Earl Release would suggest it was released prior to the official release date set by the Mint. NFN, but uh, when each year's Proof and Mint sets are released, up until the Mint discontinued the business strikes, the POTUS dollars were early releases from the official release date.

Point being, neither of those term are any more special on a TPG label than say a VAM, FB, FT, FBL designations.

It's all marketing, nothing more.

 

Are you saying First Strike and Early Release are the same as FB,FH,FBL etc. ??

 

Where did I say that?

What I said was, the First Strike, and Early Release are no more special on the label than FB, FT, FBL, VAM or any other designation TPGs place on their labels, when the coin is deserving of those designations.

 

Yep, that's what I thought you said....