Does trading PCGS Walkers for NGC Walkers straight across make sense? The reason I ask is as my set grows I get both and when I'm done I want only NGC. Or maybe a set of both. I'd like to know what your thoughts are. Thanks
imo it does make sense because really prices wise people say pcgs sells for more but this is not always the case !! I know people that swear by both companies but in reality both are the best third part grading companies around !
I have a 45D MS67 Walker in an NGC holder. The NGC price guide shows $910. On the PCGS price guide this coin in a PCGS holder is listed at $1250 (just raised last week). I would be very willing to make a trade.
On average and without seeing any images, PCGS graded WLHs sell for more than identically graded WLHs in NGC holders.
That's about what I thought. I would most likely go by the price I paid. Heck, I don't know. I don't have any ms47's. My highest grade so far is ms65, although most are ms64.
