I could guarantee ya both weren't plated. The P-Mint is an El Yunque I got at the Philly mint at a machine where you can exchange an old quarter for a one that the mint is currently minting, and at the time of my visit, it was El Yunque. The D-Mint is from Littleton (yes my parents bought them for me) and they aren't plated, as the Edge shows the bright copper.
then was the coin struck from a fresh die? Still, both the satin and brilliant have superb lusters of their kind--satiny luster and brilliant luster.
The surface finish on a business strike coin can vary considerably depending on how much polishing the die received after hardening, and how much wear the die has received through use. A new die can have a matte or a PL finish depending on the amount of polish/cleaning it received. Then through use as the die starts to wear and flowlines start to develop you can get a tight flashy luster, then as it wears more the luster band becomes more subdued and starts widening. Eventually you get a satiny finish/luster, and fianlly a worn heavily flowlined appearance.