What will PCGS grade this Buffalo

I know I said details, but I kind of wanted it to grade... Shame. Congrats to the other winners!

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I don't get the cleaning.

 

Gbroke, this is just a theory but you never know. Maybe the pcgs grader is someone here on cointalk who doesn't like you and made sure they got to grade your coins. I don't know how TPGs work so I am probably wrong but just a thought.

 

Who hates Gbroke?

 

Idk like I said just something that came to mind and I'm 99% sure I'm wrong but who knows.

 

As much as I would like that to be true, it isn't the case lol.
The coin was submitted through another member.

 

Lol I figured I was wrong.

 

MS65

 

So did I. I'm just surprised that it came back "Cleaned" of all things. That was probably the last thing on my mind when looking at the coin. I'm wondering if the PCGS graders were unsure about the metal movement and just sorta kinda made a net grade on a details coin. It's either that or they were just flat-out made a mistake. gbroke did you ever suspect a cleaning?

 

tough break, sorry dude

 

Lol GP. I know that feeling. It's like on Facebook, when someone posts that a relative or friend died, or some other terrible news...it's weird to give it a "like" lol.

 

Thank you, Greg for the contest. I am really sorry I was one of the winners, because that is a beautiful coin --- and I don't see how they can say it was cleaned.

 

MS 66, 127

 

why didn't the guy who guessed unc details cleaned win....he didn't put a cert number but he was the only one who got the grade right and the cert number was the tiebreaker? Did he not get it in on time?

 

I don't like him.

Just kidding, he was way past deadline.

 

Me and every other self respecting classic commemorative collector. His Jeff photos are so extreme in candor that they put my series to shame. Curses.........


Gotta love Greg though..........

 

Even bad press is good

 

Greg, everything about you is good.........