Guess the grade #508

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t226888/ will be ending tonight.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Did anyone not see the luster on this coin? And it has a great strike. Yes, there is a nick on the shoulder, but that is not a critical area. The nick in front of the nose probably held it back as much as the one on his shoulder. Less either of these, I think it would have made a 67, but with both, it is a solid 66. In this case, not only PCGS, but CAC agreed.

 

MNcoinman is back, but he missed a couple. Several other flip-flops, but Duke remains solidly in the lead.

Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses.

1. Duke Kavanaugh 0.240 26
2. rzage 0.337 45
3. MNcoinman 0.389 19
4. Leadfoot 0.397 31
5. bahabully 0.427 43
6. BadThad 0.432 46
7. petro89 0.432 46
8. mark_h 0.433 47
9. ldhair 0.448 30
10. ddoomm1 0.500 48

 

Sang to the tune "Solid as a rock."

 

Both right , needed that to even stay anywhere near Duke . I was worried about the 22-D almost went 65 on it . Dick so that shoulder hit doesn't look as bad in hand ?

 

Well....at least it got CAC. PCGS just being too tough with the 67 grades.

 

It is there for sure, but it is not deep enough to be that distracting. And, that shoulder is not that critical.

 

I had this one at MS66.

 

Been out of town and quite busy lately.

I return to see I've dropped like a rock!

Well done, guys!

 

Glad to see ya back Mike , now take your rightful place .

 

Man I was in the top 10 for one round!!! Dropped even after getting both of these right ARGHHH....at least I know I'm getting better.

 

BadThad 0.432 46
petro89 0.432 46

Apparently I am your doppelganger...or we are at least brothers from another mother as it were...