3 PURE SILVER Half Dollars COMMEMORATIVE - Help to Identify Them ! -

3 PURE SILVER - Old Coins COMMEMORATIVE - I need Help to Identify ... i just identify the Barber Half Dollar -


Please Help me, Thank you !

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

If they are genuine then they are all 90% silver, not pure silver. They also appear to be circulated and polished up mightily. However, given the 1795 "dollar" from the other post, I am not convinced these are real.

 

Sesquicentennial of Independence

Pilgrim Tercentenary

Barber

Panama Pacific

 

Can't really tell from these pics but something about your commemoratives makes me think Chinese fakes made recently .
How long have you had these ? Did you buy them from the internet in the past couple of years . Wish you could post better pics . Hope I'm wrong , but better pics would help immensely .

 

They all look off...might be the lighting or the pics. They do look polished.

I doubt the first 2 are fakes though you never know since everything is faked now...but they are much less likely to be fakes than the Pan-Pac is just because of its value and the fact that there are some fakes around. I don't know the Sesqui too well, but the Pilgrim looks fine from what I can tell.

 

Something does look off with the commemoratives. Barber I'm sure is OK.

 

If any of them are magnetic, they're certainly fake

 

Maybe just the pics but that Pan-Pac looks off.........

 

As does the 'Pilgrim'.........

 

Not sure about the Sesqui of American Independence. Need better pics.........on all of 'em.

 

Thank youu, they are from a NY Collection, they are authentic, but i didnt knew the types, im not expert in commemoratives. thank to all for the support and good eye !.

Question, In Value Order ?. wich one is the Best of those ?.

Sesquicentennial of Independence
Pilgrim Tercentenary
Barber
Panama Pacific

 

Awesome Information, thank you !!!

Thank youu, they are from a NY Collection, they are authentic, but i didnt knew the types, im not expert in commemoratives. thank to all for the support and good eye !.

Question, In Value Order ?. wich one is the Best of those ?.

Sesquicentennial of Independence
Pilgrim Tercentenary
Barber
Panama Pacific

 

The Pan-Pac is the more valuable........if she's the real deal.

 

Number1- Panama Pacific

2 or 3 ? wich one can be better, Indepence o Pilgrim ?.

Sesquicentennial of Independence
Pilgrim Tercentenary

 

The Sesqui and the 1920 Pilgrim are basically equals in all grades. The 1921 Pilgrim is more rare.

The Pan-Pac is more valuable than the other 3 combined...as stated...if it is real. There is something that seems off but without a more detailed picture we can't be sure.

 

I would strongly suggest not buying expensive commemoratives online with photos like that. It's like gambling.

 

Thank you petro89:

So ...

Number1 - Panama Pacific
Number2 - Pilgrim (Equal Price) More Rare than Independence.
Number3- Independence (Equal Price)

Any aproximatily Range Price ?

 

Ain't goin' there without better pics.......

 

I agree. And what's going on with the Barber's reverse?

I don't like the rim either.

 

It's just worn down.