GTG: 4 1886 Morgans: you match grade

4 beautiful 1886 Morgans all in a PCGS rattler:


All 4 coins are below. They were placed in random order. You match the coin to the grade above:

1:



2:


3:



4:

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

All Morgans are 70 to me, I win. Actually, you are the winner with those beauties. I'm partial so I'm not going to guess and embarrass myself. Thanks for sharing.

 

1. 62
2. 65
3. 64
4. 63

 

1. 62
2. 64
3. 63
4. 65

…at least that’s how they should have graded

 

I think they’re in the correct order.

 

I just began learning to grade so I'm probably
wrong but here's my guess.

1. 62
2. 64
3. 63
4. 65

 

1. 62
2. 65
3. 64
4. 63

 

I agree with:
1. 62
2. 65
3. 64
4. 63

 

I’d love to find another 1886 in a rattler in any other grade than those. I cant find one.

 

I love the rattlers and other OGHs (including the "new anniversary" addition) but yeah they getting harder and harder to come by

 

Not much action on this thread, I thought it would be a little more fun than a regular GTG.

I’ll give one of them away, which is the one with really pretty subtle rim tone. Nobody said this was the 62. Incredible for a 62:

 

Must be the heavy grazes on the high points.

 

1-63, 2-64, 3-62, 4-65

 

I was way off on that one.

 

Several got that #4 is the CAC 65. It actually has a couple of noticeable hits on the obverse. But the booming luster is truly over the top. WAY better than the other 3 (which are not lacking). The reverse is near flawless.



Down to #1 and #2. Which one is 63 and which one is 64?

 

I like that this test proved how utterly clueless I am grading Morgans. Good thing I don't collect them.

 

+1

 

Great idea for the thread. I love those old rattlers.

 

Here they are. This is where everyone says I knew it! Lol

I have an entire complete set of Morgans. So I am not entirely certain why I collected this subset. But these are all stunners: