My second PCGS submission

I had a good time guessing the grades with my first PCGS submission. I decided to start a thread here to post my guesses for this submission. I will be submitting these coins at the Baltimore show, so I probably wont see grades until May or so.

1) 1853 A&R 50C - Was in an ANACS 35 holder, and I see it holdering at the same grade
2) 1893-O 50C - Darkly toned coin, light on the liberty but great detail throughout - My grade 20
3) 1894-S 50C - lighter colored coin with ghosting of the design elements. Probably from a long ago dip - My grade 20
4) 1895 50C - My grade 20
5) 1895-O 50C - This is a gorgeous VF Barber half, it has a rim issue that might put it in a BB. My grade 25 w/o the issue, hopefully they net it at 20
6) 1900-O 50C - Perfect original color, I'm split on the grade VG10/F12 Im hoping for the 12 since it is a softly struck date.
7) 1901-O 50C - Nice look for a tough date. I say 25
8) 1902-O 50C - Weakly struck, but I think it will go 15
9) 1903-S 50C - The date that got a BB for me in my last round. I think this coin will get a solid 15
10) 1904 50C - Ex NGC 20, I see it getting the same grade
11) 1905-O 50C - The most prized piece I have acquired so far. Such a tough date, and this one is great looking. I'm thinking 25
12) 1907-O 50C - Ex NGC 12 I think it should be in a 15 holder if not a 20
13) 1908-S 50C - Nice crusty Barber, this is the look I love. I say 30
14) 1911 50C - Ex NGC 12. This should make it in a 15 holder no problem

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Justin - do you have photos for these in the other thread?

 

I posted photos of the Ex NGC and Anacs coins. I will do my best to get photos of the rest. I'm horrible at photos to say the least.

 

Here are the previously slabbed coins.

 

No you're not, now post 'em........

 

Man the 07-O definitely should get bumped from a 12 and I love the 1911. That coin is perfect if you ask me; I wish all of mine looked liked that.

 

LogPotato is a conservative grader.
I see most of his coins getting bumped a grade.
( F-12... F-15 )
Good luck !!

 

You'll get to see them anyways lol!

 

This submission has me pumped...could be the 05-O ....

 

yay!!!

 

Now the wait

 

Shouldn't be a long one......

 

Hopefully...

 

LogPotato - how did you submit ? Economy or Regular ?

My last submission for Economy was accepted January 8,
and shipped 8 weeks later. When I called to inquire, I was
told my submission was right on target. They listed "21" days
... just don't count weekend days, holidays, trips to conventions
( that eats up 4 or 5 days right there ) and as a result,
it's an 8 week ordeal waiting.

Not to be discouraged, while in Baltimore, I had two more
Economy Submissions. One with a couple of Cross Overs &
one with 17 raw Barber Halves.

I hope you get your grades soon. As, so do I.

 

Don't know how I missed your post, Mike. It's been 21 days now. I submitted the day after you at the Baltimore show. So it will be interesting to see who's gets posted first. I'm pacing frantically waiting for results. If I remember correctly, you had a few coins in that raw submission I could use in my set. :yes:

 

Justin,
My coins were accepted into the PCGS Sytem on 3/28/12. If you ignore weekends - holidays - shows - then you're right - its been 21+ days. Now take those things I mentioned into consideration, and the soonest we'll hear will be on Wednesday, May 9th.
[ There was a 3 day show in Las Vegas - plus Emancipation Day / April 16th - plus a week for Central States ] .

Sad but true.

 

I guess I will just have to wait it out.

 

Waiting is the hardest part. They've had a couple of coins of mine for 3+ weeks and every day is torture. Hope the results are worth the wait!

 

[video=youtube;uMyCa35_mOg]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uMyCa35_mOg[/video]

 

Grades in !!!!

Order #20590255 / Submission #4599352
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 24710649 6275 1853 50C Arrows and Rays USA VF30
2 1 24710650 6466 1893-O 50C USA VF25
3 1 24710651 6470 1894-S 50C USA Genuine - VF Details (92 - Cleaned)
4 1 24710652 6471 1895 50C USA VF25
5 1 24710653 6472 1895-O 50C USA VF30
6 1 24710654 6487 1900-O 50C USA F12
7 1 24710655 6490 1901-O 50C USA VF25
8 1 24710656 6493 1902-O 50C USA F12
9 1 24710657 6497 1903-S 50C USA Genuine - Fair Details (82 - Filed Rims)
10 1 24710658 6498 1904 50C USA VF25
11 1 24710659 6502 1905-O 50C USA F15
12 1 24710660 6510 1907-O 50C USA VF25
13 1 24710661 6515 1908-S 50C USA VF30
14 1 24710662 6521 1911 50C USA F15


My thoughts on this submission, nothing really surprises my other than the 05-O. That is not the right grade for that coin. It might have to take another trip in. And of course, this is my second submission and the second details 03-S. This Date MM is going to be a pain in my butt!