Guess the Grade - Two IKE's

Same Year, Same Mintmark, Same Composition, Different Grades

Care to Guess?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Ms-65 and MS-68?

 

MS66 and MS67. Looks like really severe MD on the eagle (#2)

 

I agree a 66 and 67

 

65/67

 

Close ...................but no banana.

 

65 and 67

 

L-r= ms64, ms69.

 

MS66 and MS68+

 

MS anything? Huh?

PR66 and PR67

 

"Close but no banana" had the grades right but in the wrong order.

The coin on the left is an MS68 (which I do not agree with) and the one on the right is SP65 (which I also do not agree with)

 

Where did the MS and SP come from? The only thing I can find are proofs

 

And that is based upon what?

 

The Red Book, PCGS pricing tables, NGC price guide, Numismedia etc. All only list the 1971-S as proof only.

 

7 & 8

 

Red Book has prices listed for a 1971-S silver clad Ike for both MS and PR.

Of the 6,868,530, there were 4,265,234(number appears in parenthesis represents number of proofs struck) proofs.

 

Don't ask me where my head was. I was looking under halves. HUH? Sorry!

 

We must be related?