They told me its fake because its the wrong color

The sun rays are too wide. IT IS A FAKE

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

No, and no you don't.

It doesn't have to be like all fake ones. All that matters is that this one is not real. And this one has the hallmarks of a counterfeit forged (or cast, whichever word you're most comfortable with).

It doesn't matter if it's the sole surviving example of one particular cast counterfeit, and you don't have any others of it to exactly compare it too. Even if you did, you'd be saying that both or all those exactly alike were real. And it isn't. It doesn't matter if the history regarding silver in China or other things are or aren't written about. You take several things that don't neccessarily go together, and then link them without any linkage. You are grasping at straws.

No, it doesn't fit. You are trying to make it fit, but it doesn't. It is not a possibility because the coin is fake, not real, inauthentic. I just wish this coin itself was a hallucination. Unfortunately I'm left with the fact that the coin exists and the only hallucination is you believing it to be real and fitting it into something you've read.

 

If you read the inscription backwards at half speed it says "toy coin".

 

fakety fake fake fake fake fakety fake.

OP is a troll. Do not feed the trolls.

THE END

 

tHANK You for taking the time to reply ....I just want to make it very clear ...I KNOW THIS COIN IS NOT LIKE THE ORIGINAL PEWTER COINS ..IT IS MADE OF A DIFFERENT METAL TO STAR WITH SO HOW COULD IT LOOK LIKE THE OTHERS

THERE IS NOTHING TO COMPARE IT TO THERE ARE NO OTHER FAKE COPIES OF THIS COIN THE SAME AND THE ORIGINAL COINS THEY DO HAVE ARE COMPLETELY DIFFERENT

WHY DOES IT LOOK LIKE THERE ARE REMINNTS OF OTHER LETTERS OR DESIGN THAT YOU CAN BARELY SEE ...THERE IS SOMETHING UNDERNEATHER ...OR AT LEAST THERE WAS

 

Hey, if you want the best 10th opinion (because none of us are right), then send it off to PCGS or NGC. Let's see what they say, they are the experts in authentication. That will settle this once and for all.

 

So, shut up and put it on ebay!

 

Here here!!

 

Cointalk Rule 4 – Multiple posts and/or threads.

If you have a question, please, first consider the appropriate section of the forum to place your question. If you don’t know, that’s fine, just the pick the one you think is best. However, it is only necessary to ask your question or make your comment ONCE ! Please do not make multiple posts or threads on the same subject, even if they are in different areas or forum sections. Somebody will see your question or comment no matter where you put it and provide an answer if they can. I have yet to ever see a question that could not be answered by somebody on Coin Talk.

And please, use some patience. Not everybody is on-line every minute of the day. Usually a question will be answered within a few hours at most. But if your question is not answered immediately, be patient. Some members only visit the site every few days.

Read more: http://www.cointalk.com/t34131/#ixzz1nFo0khjG​

 

On the flip side, you can see "toidi na yb denwo si nioc ekaf siht"

 

Fake

 

Wait a second...I think he may be right about something here:

 

If you want to truly know if it is authentic, then by all means, send it to a TPG and wast a bunch of money and have it sent back as fake. 'Nuff said.

 

I thought it said: Always drink your Ovaltine?

 

ACTUALLY THERE WERE TWO MR WILLIAM MURDOCH (MURDOCK)

ON THE TITANIC

Mr William Murdock (1), was born on 18 September 1878 in Clifton, Bristol (2). He lived at 78 Thorndyke Street, Belfast

 

lololololol

 

I have a theory also......maybe the story was made up by one of your family members to make it sound amazing.

 

the were only a few coins from mr murdock and they are all dated before 1912

 

.

 

Worthless images support the facts that this coin is nothing but a novelty item.