I can't agree with that 100% since I haven't collected a lot of series. I will say though, you don't see very many problem free VF-XF halves. And this is what I am currently doing. Collecting in the F12-VF25 range. I think when I do complete it....and that will be a very long time from now...I would like to do a VG set in a Dansco similar to what you are doing. I really love the Barber series and the halves just really speak to me.
By the way, I know RB has a personal issue with plastic (which is OK ) I decided to throw some of my raw Barber Halves into the PCGS grading circus. Here is a synopsis. [TABLE="width: 97%"] [TD="class: ftalternatingbaron, width: 99%, bgcolor: #FEF6EF, align: right"][TABLE="width: 100%"] [TD="colspan: 2"]Well, I have been collecting Barber halves in F-VF for a small amount of time now, and I figured it was time to put my grading to the test. Most of these coins are common, but I really enjoy this series, and I wanted to use this as a learning experience. I have few more raw sitting in my Dansco waiting for plastic tombs, but I figured 8 was enough for my first time submitting. 1) 1898-S Bought from a dealer at the Pitt ANA. The dealer warned me he felt it was a VG10 coin, and I trust his expertise. I just like the coin so much I wanted to take the shot at an F-12 2) 1899 Bought from another forum member. This is a strong F15 coin in my opinion. 3) 1902 Bought from the same forum member. A very crusty piece that should make F15 on it's worst day. I hope for a VF20. 4) 1903-S Again, from the same member. A lighter coin with good detail. I expect a VF20 grade but would not be surprised with a VF25 grade. 5) 1905-S Another raw purchase from the Pitt ANA. I feel this coin has a strong chance at an F15, but wouldn't be disappointed with an F12 grade. 6) 1908 A raw purchase from the Philly Whitman show this year. I think it has a good chance at VF20. 7) 1910-S Bought from the same forum member as mentioned above. This coin has all the best qualities in a F-VF Barber half. I would like a VF20, but I feel it's a strong F15. 8) 1913-D Bought from the same forum member above, I belive this coin should get a VF20, but wouldn't be surprised if it got a F15. As always, grades are subjective, and I plan on absorbing as much as I can out of this experience. Of course if I get a body bag, it will go back in the Dansco as if it never took the tip to California in the first place. I will post the grades, as soon as I get them.[/TD] [/TABLE] [/TD] [/TABLE]
My recent purchases of Barber Dimes. Sorry for my poor quality pics :smile .............:smile :smile :smile
I'm really looking forward to seeing how they turn out Log. Please be sure to share the results with us. Good Luck! IMO Slabs have their place. Most of my key dates are in slabs. I do love the look and feel of raw coins though.
I love the feel of raw coins as well. That's why I buy duplicates if I like them and put them in my Dansco. I like to buy the better pieces I can find in the PCGS holders or put them in there. I am not the best at taking care of coins, and I would like to protect my "investment" as best I can. Slabs offer the best option in that scenario for me. I tend to favor PCGS and I'm still not really sure why. I think a pq coin in a PCGS slab offers the best situation for the persons that might someday inherit my collection. Just an opinion.
I have been working on a set of raw Barber halves for several years. They are in a Dansco album and I just need two more, 1892P and 1893S. For the 1892-S and 1892-O I couldn't find raw coins so I had to buy slabbed. I probably will not crack them out.
I'm not sure if I posted this set here yet. [And I am too lazy to go thru 49 pages to look] So, if I did please ignore me. Barber Half Dollars -- 1892 to 1915 Well, this is my set #1 for the half dollars. Again, I have some better, but most are slabbed. Anyone want to see quarters?
08-D, 12-S, and 13-S are my favorites. ... Awh, heck, they're all gorgeous! Fantastic set, Treashunt. :thumb: -Brian
Stop by Holsonbake Numismatics table at FUN. I just received a consignment of AU Barber Quarters ... None of the Big Three - and - the 09-O in 55 is mine - sorry ... :yes: Mike Hayes ELBESAAR