I agree. Melt. There are a few dealers that continue to pay a slight premium for dollars, but I think those two you show would still be melt.
I think the Walker is a 1916, not '40. At least that's the way it looks to these old eyes. I think you can edit your post to correct both mistakes.
I agree, melt value (P.S. Melt does not mean to melt the coins. It is a term used in short for "silver value")