Help me learn to properly grade coins.

I have a little thing I want to do here on CT.
I want to get better at grading coins

So I am requesting that you post a picture of your coin WITHOUT THE GRADE!!!!
And allow me time to view the image and provide a grade.

If I am right let me know. If I am wrong, after three guesses tell me what the real grade was.

No prizes, just a learning experiment.

Any and all graded coins welcome, however I prefer US COINS

So what do ya say, will you help me learn to grade coins?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

This is a great link for viewing graded coins of different denominations.

http://www.pcgs.com/Photograde/#

I'm not trying to brush you off, just giving that link to you as a guide for the different grades of coins as you can study those photos and see what the graders saw when they gave the grades listed for the coins in the photos.

I'm sure all of us are more than willing to assist you as best we can.

Another helpful guide is in the beginning of Redbook, on page 9 I believe, is the conditions for each grade level and what to look for. Also each price guide section has a description of what to look for on the particular denomination and strike, for the different grade levels.

I hope you know it will take more than overnight to learn grading

 

true however it ruins the surprise as it tells you the grade when you look at the photo (not trying to shut you down either just been to the PCGS photograde website already)

 

True it does show you the grade. That way you can see a MS68 wheatie and look at both sides to see what the graders saw when they graded the coin MS68

You also need to understand, that coin grading is highly subjective. What one TPG says is MS66 FBL, another may say MS64 with no FBL. What TPGs grade any coin, is nothing more than their opinion of the grade and should be taken as such.

 

Here's a toughie to start you off.

 

And this one is a bit easier..

 

Try this one

 

I am probably way off but that's why I am doing this.
It appears as though the entire luster is gone, the details are still quite fine I can still see the lines in the bell. As well as most some of the lines in the wood on the bell.

Merc Crazy Is your half dollar coin:
XF-49??

Thanks for posting.

 

Indeed a good bit off.

 

I think an obverse and reverse are necessary here.

 

Is your Morgan Dollar PF-687?

 

Wow, I wish.

Worth noting that while there may be rare, rare examples of branch mint proofs (Even those are questionable though), all true Morgan proofs were minted in Philly.

 

How about VF-34?

 

Lol I ment PF-67 but it's proof? It appears as though it is.

Is it MS-65

And that's good to know about the proofs because I did not know proof morgans were only minted in Philly

 

You're going the wrong way... but that is a really tough coin to grade.

 

Half looks like a 64 or 65 hard to see if it's FBL.

The Morgan I'll guess 65, maybe PL.

 

It's not proof, but it carries the PL designation. MS65 is incorrect, though.

 

And non-gold would be easier to start with too.

 

There is a thread already devoted to this . Grading coins from pictures.

 

But I think the OP wants to learn grading whether from pics or in hand.