Check out this raw 1883 Shield Nickel on eBay. Item 130477276009. 1883 5c. Shield Nickel GEM Proof The seller describes the nickel as "GEM Proof". I see nothing that would make me think the coin is a Proof. It looks like a Business Strike to me. Look at the photos and let me know whether you think it is Proof or a Business Strike. Auctiva Photos
It is very hare to tell the difference between a business strike and a proof when it comes to the Liberty nickels. After examining the nickel in question I would like to call it a proof, but the photographs just aren't good enough to determine the subtle differences in the field and devices for a definite call. Perhaps there some pros in this forum who can determine what the coin is with more clarity.
The image is lousy, but I believe the coin is a Proof. My reasons are as follows: Most business strike 1883 Shield Nickels are not prooflike. The coin displays light cameo contrast, which would be very unusual for a business strike, as opposed to a Proof. I know the seller. He is knowledgeable, and, based on my dealings with him, honest.
It looks like a proof. Strongly struck with full details -- I can't recall seeing a business strike 1883 shield that strong. Mirrored fields and in between the lines of the shield without any evidence of lapping of a business strike die. All that says proof to me. FWIW, I looked at the coin and formed my opinion before reading any comments to the thread. After reading them, Mr. Feld's in particular, and going back and looking at the seller, I agree with Mark on all counts. Proofs of this type and period aren't too hard to distinguish in-hand, IMO, so it's worth a shot if interested. What made you think business strike? The photos are a bit odd (lit from a low angle), but I don't see ANYTHING that suggests business strike to my eye and I found your question curious.
Maybe it is the photos or, as you suggested, the lighting. Portions of the coin do not look as sharply struck as I would expect on a Proof (denticles, scrolls around shield, etc.) The stars are very sharply struck. Then again maybe I was up too late. Thanks for the input., guys
