The Toning Premium Thread

That's a good point baha but I keep them pretty much all in the SDB so it's not a worry.

And that was a great price you got that last toner for. Nice pick up and Krypto you got more for that price

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'm hoping he gives the CT folks first shot at the new load from FUN before they hit the 'bay.... maybe a cost + 5% blue tag sale on the 'CT would turn them fast-fast for ya.. lest they go 'bay and you have to mess with all that documentation, fees, and work (blech),, think of the ease of it Shane !?

 

Im hoping Shane has some stunner dimes!

 

Okay, here is a rainbow toned full step Jefferson Nickel from a no reserve E-Bay auction last month.



PCGS Price Guide is $35 for MS65 FS and $140 for MS66 FS.

 

I'll guess the pics were not that good, and you picked it up at $75.

 

$120 is my guess and I like it.

 

Seller's photos are always pretty decent, but they come with a free glass of juice!

 

$90 Nice toning on pretty much a run-of-the -mill coin.

 

It was actually a couple months ago and I wont guess since I tracked that auction!:foot-mouth:

 

$175, beautiful

 

$110 is my guess

 

Once again I'll stay on the low side with $100.

It's interesting to me that any of the posted guesses so far might be right—meaning that, even after all the "practice" that's taken place on this thread, with guesses and explanations by some very knowledgeable people, that toning premiums seem as unpredictable as ever. There are so many factors, maybe with the main one being that some of you can spot gems in the rough among all the bad photos on ebay.

(That might define the low side, with the high side maybe defined by someone's sheer desire to own a particular toner.)

 

150

 

+1

 

Beautiful as usual , $245 .
rzage

 

I say $220.

 

Price was $160, Look who is up, again!

 

Okay I just found this thread so here it is a 1955 Proof Roosevelt NGC PF69 "Star" Cameo Numismedia Retail Price $425

 

I'll stab at $1100.

BTW, gorgeous coin!

 

$600 for the dime