what are these worth and how would you grade them

these 2 coins have been super kept over the years there 2 newfoundland 50 cent pieces one is 1904 and the other 1919.. tell me what you think thanks

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Can you take some up close pics?

 

They are worth investing in a Standard Catalog of World Coins guide

 

How much bigger would you like them? They go up to about 4 inches a coin on my screen. It shows the whizzing real clearly - on both. And I do not know what cleaning does to the value of Canadian coins.

 

Whizzing will destroy the numismatic value of any coin.

Chris

 

definitely whizzed

 

Here is a link you may find helpful: http://www.georgemanzcoins.com/newfoundland/50cents.html

 

newfoundland 50 cents

i have lots of newfoundland coins. how can you tell for sure when something is cleaned? i have maybe 8 or 10 of each of these the same year. i also have some in super condition. but what is the way to tell if they are cleaned..im thinking some of my coins have been stored for many years. could a well kept coin be mistaken as cleaned because they are in such good shape? thanks also are diff years struck with different depth of detail. less maybe to make it actually look worn...thanks

 

If you could provide us with better photo's of the coins, perhaps we could offer up an opinion . Can't, with these. The lighting is unbalanced .