Guess the grade #429

1936-D PCGS slabbed

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Ms-67rd

 

67 red. I'm assuming nearly all the scratches on the front are on the slab.

 

I said 66, will see

 

66

 

67

 

almost went 67 again, but america looks kinda weird, could be die issue though ... 66 is my guess

 

Went 66 but could see a 67 there as it's nice.

 

This and http://www.cointalk.com/t214557/ will be ending tonight.

 

Went 66 , but could see 67 if those rubs in the right field are magnified .

 

Great strike and luster. The discolorations are not so bad in hand. Obvious, but not bad. However, there are a couple nicks and a couple spots. I am not sure either would keep it from a 67, but both together definitely do. It is a 66. A solid 66, but PCGS and I agree.

 

Don't know what to say Dick, I knew this would grade 66, but I just couldn't do it this time. The weak right wheat, obv nicks, and color keep this from a 66 for me.

 

I agree, solid 66!

 

I am not exactly sure what you are seeing for nick, though there are some minor ones, but those wheats are all strongly there. I really do not see what you are seeing either in hand or on the picture.

 

The kernels look great, the "hairs" above the kernels look mushy. I'm probably just seeing things. Anyway, live and learn, I've just seen you post many 66's that blow this one away in my mind.

 

Light reverse strike won't hold a coin back from 67, much less 66, IMO.

 

Really? Can't say I've run across many light struck 67's.
Anyway, I got it wrong. 66 it is.

 

I'll have to look it up in the PCGS book , but I'm pretty sure ANA 6th edition says a 67 must be strongly struck .