I went 63 also, but as has been said, AU58 would shock me either. Hard to tell what caused the weakness above the ear (strike or wear). Is that an old scratch running through the ear and up into abe's forhead ?,, and a fresher ding on the nose ?
I'm glad that 58 isn't a choice. AU63 here. No shot at RB unless the coloring is much lighter in person than in the image.
Nothing spectacular about the coin, but it is a 1914-S - and a woody to boot. However, there is no wear that you can really pick out in hand. It is a fair strike with minimal marks although it does have a couple small spots. That averages out to a descent 63 for me. See http://www.cointalk.com/t151640/