New auction win - Joining the Owl club!

Discussion in 'Ancient Coins' started by Michael Stolt, Jul 15, 2021.

  1. iameatingjam

    iameatingjam Well-Known Member

    I want to know how athenian owls of the ~450BC-404BC were so uniform in the first place. anyone?
     
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. sand

    sand Well-Known Member

    That's a good question. They all seem to have the same design elements. They all seem to have been minted in Athens. Perhaps researchers have figured out more specific dates, based on minor design variations (Athena smiling or not, the style of the A-theta-E, the style of other design elements, flan size, etc), and based on archaeological evidence. I don't know. I'm not an expert, in the area of Athena/Owl tetradrachms.
    I Googled the following :
    Athena owl tetradrachm variations
    I only looked at the first page of Google results.
    I found one interesting article, which seems to have some relevant information, regarding your question. The author calls these "classical" owls "mass owls" :
    http://rg.ancients.info/owls/
    I haven't read the entire article thoroughly, but I found some interesting items. In the article, the author says the following :
    "Despite the popularity of Mass Owls, their dating and attribution is one of the great underexplored areas of ancient numismatic scholarship. Chester Starr in 1970 called this area a "wasteland" and said a die study of these coins, because of their sheer numbers, would be a "terrific labour." Peter van Alfen in 2009 described Mass Owls as "notoriously untrainable issues." Because of the number of dies used, David Sear told me in a 2009 email interview that he hasn't found a single die match over the years involving any of the Owls sent to him to authenticate..."
    However, the author seems to attempt to analyze the variations. He says the following :
    "Mass Owls that were likely issued earlier, compared with those issued later, tend to have the following characteristics:
    Athena has a wider, smiling mouth that can appear as a smirk rather than a short mouth that's neutral in affect or that curves slightly downward, forming a frown.
    Athena has a more protruding rather than a flatter face.
    The eye of Athena is smaller and more symmetrical, with the curve forming the upper half mirroring the curve forming the lower half, rather than the two sides being asymmetrical.
    The floral scroll on Athena's helmet is smaller rather than larger.
    The owl has shorter rather than longer claws.
    The ethnic consists of smaller rather than larger letters.
    The incuse square is more clearly visible on the coin's flan rather than being off it."
    He also says a bunch of other stuff, which I haven't read thoroughly. Maybe I'll read it later.
    So this article may be helpful.
    Also, there may be other helpful articles, on the other pages of Google results, or from other Google searches.
     
    Last edited: Jul 16, 2021
    Gam3rBlake and Roman Collector like this.
  4. FitzNigel

    FitzNigel Medievalist Supporter

    As with any ancient coin, I think we need to be comfortable with a degree of ambiguity, particularly when it comes for dating. To within 50 years isn’t bad considering we are nearly 2500 years removed from their montage. Luckily there is a recent book on the coins of Athens which I would highly recommend
     
    iameatingjam likes this.
  5. Arcane76

    Arcane76 Well-Known Member

    37DE1615-4C99-435F-99A8-EA64150D3857.jpeg 82BB0461-B755-4747-AB60-63FA9B6DE73A.jpeg My owl. I don’t mind the test cut, I mind the bad pictures I took of it
     
  6. kolyan760

    kolyan760 Well-Known Member

    you shouda bought from me for way less of the price
     
  7. Michael Stolt

    Michael Stolt Well-Known Member

    Updating with some photos and a video now that the coin has arrived. It is superb in hand.



    IMG_20210813_193653063_HDR.jpg
    IMG_20210813_193713761_HDR.jpg
     

    Attached Files:

    FitzNigel, Curtisimo, akeady and 8 others like this.
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page