Guess this grade.

I just got this back from PCGS today. Any guesses on what it graded?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

WOW! What a BEAUTIFUL coin! :thumb:

I don't know how to grade these, but if I had to guess, I'd say low MS

 

Ms64, (completely random guess)

 

Looks to be AU58. Beautiful Coin!

 

Winner gets a free barber quarter. One guess per person. Contest closes at 7pmCST

 

Can it be the same as another person's guess?

 

The first correct guess gets it. May or may not have already been guessed.

2nd person to get it wins a free buffalo nickel! Hows that?

 

Okay then, can I change my "low MS" to AU-55 since I didn't know?

 

Arg... I can't tell if it a weak strike or wear... does it have luster? If it does can you get pictures that show it?

 

Dude, come on, thats a great pic! How many people on ebay even give you pics that good to go by? Just do the best you can.

Here is a huge version to use:
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3647/3554615857_320d991dd3_o.jpg

 

guess

ms 66

 

WOW! Nice coin -
It is really hard to tell this grade, but my gut says AU58.
Most of the time I would say around 63, but I just don't see any luster, and the details looks worn/weak in a few places on the REV.

Speedy

 

Alright I changed to AU55 still nobody has said it but me.

 

Now that I've seen the larger pic, I know it isn't MS.
I'm going to stick with my 58 because this is PCGS grading it, and it has a REALLY nice strike, but I'm thinking that it could have even gotten a 45.

Speedy

 

Not knowing FE's. I would say AU-50. Maybe AU-53.

 

ms-60

 

Since the AUs are taken, I'm gonna' say MS61.

 

Guess again, I already said that (I changed mine at 7:27, you did yours at 7:37).

 

WE HAVE A WINNER!

 

Congratulations! I still think I should have been the winner.:high5: