DGS Graded Saint/ Guess Grade

Once again... just want to get opinions.... I will post actual grade of this coin later today.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Better Pics

This should help

 

personally, the obverse looks AU-58.

But, probably graded MS.

 

The lighting is making it really tough to tell wear. I think it's probably an MS61. I can see it as an AU58 though.

 

Au 63

 

Ms60

 

XF

Speedy

 

63/64

 

I'm going to say its MS60 as I don't see any wear. Too many marks in my opinion for it to grade higher though, even if it is a large gold coin.

 

AU. Looks like wear on the knee.

 

I was thinking MS62 - could be the lighting making it look all ticked up and I am not any good at grading gold.

 

Au58

 

Those were my thoughts. I could see it going much lower on the AU scale due to the clutter - and the weak strike on the torch. Maybe AU53.

 

Yup -- that's what I say when I'm not sure.

Seriously, that coin is a classic slider, IMO. Could go 58 one day, could go 63 another -- that's what I meant.

Was a bit surprised DGS called it a 58. Encouraged, actually...Mike

p.s. DLRC scans make it practicually impossible for me to distinguish sliders - as wear/luster is the distinguishing factor and this very factor comes out poorly in scans, and the TPGS are anything but consistent.

 

p.s. I think Speedy just took the Scrooge title away from you, GDJMSP.

 

AU-58 , nice , not enough time again .
rzage

 

ROTFL!!!!

Speedy