It appears that NGC overgraded it. I hope you paid 65 or 66 money for it, but regardless of the grade, a very beautiful piece.
I would say 64. I can't judge the luster or whether those are hits on the shoulder or marks on the slab. The toning is also neutral imo.
I thought I was dubbed Insider2 after our little argument, insider! :D:rolleyes::hilarious:
I would say 66.
I'm "Nope-ing" out of here right now before a CAC debate begins.
64. I think the hits on the obverse plus the weak reverse strike prohibits a higher grade. Thanks for sharing, LeHigh.
Normally I hate moderns, but CircCam, that bottom Silver dollar, is ah-mazing....... <3 The bird is so perfect!!! If the U.S. put that on a...
Ok let's see if someone can post some gorgeous key date Indians...... <3
Um, dude. This thread was posted 13, yes, 13****** years ago. I don't think many of these members still even post, and CAC certainly wasn't in...
It makes perfect sense from the analysis of your replies. All you have done is refute and deflect what the other members have said, and dodged an...
Ok then until you want to reveal the big secret, stop justifying your apparently spurious actions. Why are you even posting here if your goal is...
Why in the world are you being so cryptic and why do you keep avoiding the million dollar question as to WHY you artificially toned the coin in...
edited I could not for the life of me, stifle a laugh at this. :hilarious::hungover: Are they still even discussing Numismatics??
Read Jason's first reply, then read the replies from @Insider. Two of the forum's most knowledgeable people. There's your answer.
I honestly think he's trying to add to the discussion, but all he really does is aggarvate. Like ok. We disagree with the PCGS fanboys. But can we...
Typecoin- what is your problem. There's a lot of garbage I don't especially approve of in the hobby, but I don't make it my goal to harp about...
I think the heavy die polish on the obverse wiped out the letters in the legend. Not a doubled die but an interesting coin nonetheless.
That was my point. My Coin was market/value graded.
You don't think that coin has been cleaned?
Not at all, I love LeHigh, and Coin forums would never be the same without him. Doesn't stop me from being blunt.
Separate names with a comma.
