Guess the Grades

here is my whole collection of good coins all graded by ngc/pcgs. I would like some opionens of the grades before i post them and of the values.

http://picasaweb.google.com/djlljd/Coins

In the order as shown the first is a
1880 S Morgan pcgs
1943 S walker pcgs
1862 3 cent silver pcgs
1838 D buff ngc
1944 D merc ngc
1906 indian OLD OLD pcgs
1926 S oregan trail commen NGC
1884 3 cent nickel NGC
1940 D merc pcgs
and my favorite 1826 Bust Half pcgs

Thank you

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Oh, mint grading is not my strong point.

1944-D Mercury Dime, MS-64
1940-D Mercury Dime, MS-66 (I want to say 65) - I assume the scratches are on the slab.

... or vice versa

 

the 40 D merc has tons of marks on the holder and so do many other ones

BTW does anyone know a good way to clean the holder?

 

Morgan - MS64 maybe PL or DMPL and the indian 64 RB - not sure if those are shadows on front and back or what, but it looks like more than 5-10% brown mixed in. I would not be surprised if it was red, could just be the pictures and lighting.

 

really only a ms-64 on the indian?

 

I'll check in later....takin pics tonight...Monday chores in other words

 

oh and yes there is some Brown hiding in the shadows of that indian

 

dang i was hoping for some more responses

 

"Please" and "Thank You" might help...

 

could people please comment on my coins/photography

Thank you

 

Wow, very nice coins man, and nice photo's too! :thumb:

Phoenix

 

I've used this stuff called PlastX from Meguiars to clean scatches on plastic and plexiglass it works great. Never tried it on a slab before.

 

thanks but i would prefer a tested and tried product that i know done correctly cannot hurt the coin

 

sorry for resurrecting this old thread of mine but i was wondering if anyone could please give me more opinions about the grades of my coins.

Thanks

 

If they are already graded why the opinions then?

 

Well I feel the Indian Head is higher then 64 for sure.

 

There is a section in Numismatic Photography that talks about how to polish slabs.

 

tpgs can get it wrong