Looks really clean and in my experience they are kinda lenient on the grading of this improper planchet errors so I say MS66.
I'll make a compromise and say here that you were 1 point too low. No one reads all the comments right so all isn't fully revealed.
Right and that's funny. I said the colors of that coin were throwing me off. Thanks for letting me sleep better! Lol Good night
That slab is from back when PCGS used the Series & Coin # system (15-20 years ago), but when did they use grey labels? Or is that a light blue label that just faded? Btw, that coin is as cool as the other side of the pillow.
I believe it is the generation you are thinking of https://www.pcgs.com/holders/Gen4.0 And it did either fade or they had different labels at some point.