I actually have some that aren't toned! Here is a neat silver proof with some lovely rim toning: And some that aren't silver!
I have no doubt you would enjoy it too, gbroke. It actually does have a sliver of orange on the 12 oclock area on the obverse; it's just very slight. I like to jest the toner nuts...not that I'm bias at all...
I would just as easily take some of those nickels you have been showing lately... some real beauties from what I've seen!!
I don't collect Roosies, but I do collect 'Coins With A Story'. This one has two stories... First... It's thought that these were given away or awarded to a tiny number of selected attendees at the ANA show in Chicago in 1991. I've seen many other coins with the same certification number (145534-xxx), but only one other with the "ANA Centennial" pedigree (suffix number 085 to my 084). Second, the coin inside is actually a 1959-D and would grade at least MS66 (with a shot at M67) today.