1 more fav Here one Grandpa gave to me 1960 1961???I am not sure of year.at my age you just try to recall date. I just recall who gave it to me.and below there a sideshow of most of my world coin . http://s639.photobucket.com/albums/uu114/jelloman1950/1-world coins/?albumview=slideshow
There is no way for me to pick one, so I will pick 4. My choices have nothing to do with quality or value. These are the coins have shaped my collecting. Please save your questions until the end. 1. 1804 Large Cent This is the coin that started it all for me. It was part of a collection given to me by my Dad. It has been in our family since 1815. We know this for sure. What we don't know is why it was kept. We don't believe my relative was a collector, since this was the only coin the came through the family. Maybe he liked the cud, or maybe it was just a coin thrown in a drawer. We will never know. We are certainly lucky though. It is an S-266 die state B, the rarest of the 1804 large cents. I know, I need new images. But obviously, this coin isn't sitting around my house. 2. 1964 Kennedy Half Dollar I have well over 600 toned beauties, but this is my absolute favorite. It has nothing to do with value obviously. These are my favorite colors for toned coins. I call them "salsa" colors. The colors are very vibrant, and it is truly a site to behold. Every time I see it, I want to dance. 3. 1885 Morgan Dollar This was a baptismal gift to me from my great aunt. Sentimental value is through the roof. I will always cherish it. I will give up my toners before I ever give up this coin. Not that anyone would want it lol. 4. 1945 P Jefferson silver war nickel Finally, the first coin I ever bought at the first coin show I went to. This was right when I became interested in toners and nickels. That being about 3 years ago. I remember how frustrated I was when I originally took images of it to show off on CT. It was brutal. This was the beginning of my Jefferson obsession. Thanks for the great thread! -greg
Super post. Although no explanations are needed as to why any coin is your favorite, your personal attachment to these are well stated and understood.
Here ya a few more faves Dimes all types US+World. If it has the words 10 cent + Silver I am going to get one or have 1. Seated+Roosevelt silver dime are 1 of the most over look US coins made! World Dimes or 10 cent+Silver is overlooked too that is my 2c.:kewl:
My three favorites are: Favorite Jefferson Nickel--1941-D NGC MS67* 5FS: By far the most extravagantly toned regular issue Jefferson Nickel I have ever seen and the king of my registry collection. Favorite Morgan Dollar--1886 NGC MS64* Battle Creek: I dubbed this coin the "pink eye dollar" and the originality and beauty of the toning is just phenomenal. Favorite Commemorative--1900 Lafayette Dollar PCGS MS65: Words just don't do this coin justice but Mark Goodman's photos do! ENJOY!
My Favorite! I am actually surprised that my favorite is not a U.S. coin, but I fell in love with this thing the moment I saw it! It has since become my favorite coin. This guy just looks like someone you would not want to tick off...
No way I could pick just one favorite either... but these are a few that I way "overpaid" for if you were to compare with the price guides, but I still think they were great buys
Mike, That might be the most fantastically attractive Barber Half Dollar I have ever seen. That color scheme combined with absolutely dripping luster is to die for. Could you imagine if that coin had MS67 surfaces?
I am intrigued as to how it was determined that this was a matt proof as opposed to a very nice circulation strike.
It is true that some matte proofs can easily be confused with a really nice circulation strike. The similar appearance between them made them quite unpopular at the time as collectors were used to the traditional proofs w/ mirrored surfaces. That said, once you see enough matte proofs in hand, you can usually spot them out as they do have a different look to them, especially in higher grades. When going off of a photo, or when dealing with a lower graded example, there are various diagnostics to look for to know it's a proof and not a business strike. For the 1909, there are several die polish lines in the obverse field just off of Lincoln's nose that are on nearly all 1909 matte proofs. There is also a die line that runs perpendicular to Lincoln's shoulder that runs a little more than halfway to the ER of LIBERTY. Other years of matte proofs have other things to look for. Of course, unless the photos are taken just right, these can be hard to see in a photo.