Guess the Grade 1942 Walking Liberty Half Dollar in older NGC holder

And another.
BTW, this was only 2 of 4 I looked at.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Yeah this is what makes Walking Lib's one of the tougher series to grade, weak strikes.
Weak strikes give the impression of wear, but, the only way to know for sure whether there is wear or a weak strike is to look for breaks in the luster, particularly on the high-points. Unfortunately you can only do that with the coin in-hand. Since the OP didn't list AU-58 as one of the options I think it's safe to assume the coin is MS.

 

MS-66, USD$105

 

looks a little sunny to me, can't make out anything from thoses photos

 

Here are the links;
http://coins.ha.com/c/item.zx?saleNo=131350&lotNo=22724
http://coins.ha.com/c/item.zx?saleNo=131350&lotNo=22245

 

same photos that are posted, can't see to much light, also remember, its apples, for apples, both photos I posted are 1942(s) so we know theres nice ones out there

 

I think he left us a hint: I noticed when I copied his photos, he renamed them to: 57 dollars and 54 cents, and the other side was 57 dollars and 55 cents ???????????

 

You wanted 42-S, try these (but I cannot control Heritage's lighting). BTW, these are MS65's.
http://coins.ha.com/c/item.zx?saleNo=1189&lotNo=8525
http://coins.ha.com/c/item.zx?saleNo=1189&lotNo=8524

 

MS65$73-84

 

I'm in the MS65 camp; around $75

 

MS-65, $70

 

ms65 sold for $85

 

Alright thanks all for participating this coin grade ms64 but sold for $86 dollars on ebay !!

 

64 and $57

 

65 and 87.50

 

Ms64 for $85