CSNS Morgan Dollar PCGS Walk Through GTG's

Here are 3 coins I'm going to be walking through at PCGS at CSNS tomorrow.

Thoughts?

Coin 1: 1880 O Morgan


Coin 2: 1880 O Morgan


Coin 3: 1890 S Morgan

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

1880-O #1: MS64+ Pretty clean but I think the rim bump and chatter behind the nose are enough to disqualify from gem grade

1880-O #2: MS63 PL

1890-S: MS66 I think the reverse is not premium gem but the fantastic obverse should carry the coin to premium gem grade.

 

I hope one of those 80 O's nab a 64... both would be nice...

 

#1: Split grade 64/65 - the hit on the nose hurts.
#2: 64, poss PL.
#3: 65+

PS: Can I metal detect your back yard?

How do you get this stuff!

 

Why don't we have a smirky smilie?

 

It has taken me years of very hard work to earn a reputation that allows me to see these treasures come in my door. I do consider myself truly blessed.

 

I'm going to say 64 on all 3. The hits on the first 1880-O really kill me, but I think they will give it a 64. The second one...might get PL. Hard to say based on the photos.

 

64, 63, 65 (maybe)

 

64,63, 64+ (The obverse pic on the last coin is grainy. I can't judge it properly)

 

All three are very nics MS coins. 64, 63, 64. and I would like them in my collection.

 

64, 64, 64. All have beautiful surfaces, but all three have hits in significant places that would spoil obvious gem coins otherwise. The 90s is darn close to a 66, but the bad rim nick kills that. I agree with our good Dentist on the 80 o being a possible PL--the reflectivity looks there, but hard to establish that with a photograph.

 

so, any word?

 

Tomorrow.

 

What are your grade predictions Matt?

 

Shot 64, 63PL, 65+

 

Any word on the grades?

 

Took them a long time but they went 62, 62PL, and 65

 

Not a sole went that low on 1 and 2. Not even Doug.