fretboard

I have never cleaned coins before mainly b/c I've come across quite a few blackened disasters and from what I've read. I have a couple of dimes that I need to dip and I am wondering which dip I can use that works without proving to be a bad idea?

Treashunt

none of them?

__________________
The Other Frank
"Buy The Book Before The Coin!"
Buy The Book before the Book:
http://www.whitmanbooks.com/Default....tID=079482580X

GDJMSP

Pretty much true. You should never even attempt to dip a coin worth anything UNTIL you know what you are doing.

__________________
knowledge ..... share it

elaine 1970

never clean a coin. that's it.

desertgem

Since probably less than half of collectors/dealers oppose it, it is generally accepted by the market. Dipping is destructive in nature. It can only be done so much without irreversibly damaging the coin and maybe drastically reducing it's value.

The experience needed, is to be able to identify that dipping has occurred, and then estimating if you can do it "one mo time" with out crossing over to the damaged side. Many older coins may be on that thin line. If a silver coin has a value about bullion plus a little, dip away and watch to see if the luster and any cartwheel effect disappear or only the dark toning. Also be aware that removing dark covering ( which may have been out there intentionally) may reveal other problems with the coin.

When someone ( and I will also), says don't do it, we are assuming if one has to ask, they don't have the experience. So how does one get that? Some have lost good money getting experience on good coins. If you practice on coins that are melt value, you can get experience without changing their value as melt.

Now as to your question, I will answer so you stay away from battery acid, etc ( which work, but .....) EZest ( the old jeweluster ) seems the best. However, I would recommend you use some diluted 1 part EZ to 5 parts water to slow down the process and give you more time to see what is going on. You can discard the solution and make another one if necessary. Dipping a coin into the container, contaminates the solution and can transfer to other coins.

Again, I understand curiosity in people, God knows it will kill me some day, but I have only used 3 of my "lives" so far , so I know you will try it, but you will be happier if you practice a lot first. Also know that dips can have different effects on clad coins, and I have no experience there. IMO.

Jim

desertgem

I just type too much!
Yes

Phil Ham

I have cleaned coins by wiping them with a rag or even my finger nail to remove gunk. Of course, they were coins that were nearly worthless in the first place. I think everyone has wiped a coin from time to time if they've been collecting for awhile. I wouldn't do it to a 1909S VDB cent, 1916D Mercury dime, or a 1928 Peace dollar though.

TomCorona

Pretty much true. You should never even attempt to dip a coin worth anything UNTIL you know what you are doing.

Hence...part of the reason for asking how to do it.

fretboard

Yes I was surprised when I went to one of my favorite coin shops and asked the question. I was told to go ahead and dip. Not only did one of the owners tell me to dip but they also sell some type of cleaner. I was totally surprised by his answer. Needless to say, I will be especially careful if I ever buy any silver from them. In the past I have only bought gold coins and tokens from them, oh yeah and 2 silver dollars neither look like they have ever been cleaned.

Well as far as becoming a dipper myself, I think I will pass, for now. Maybe I will revisit the idea at a later date but not anytime soon.

GDJMSP

What is there to know Tom ? Rather obviously you dip the coin in the liquid and pull it out - Voila ! a dipped coin.

But there is so much more to it than that for each and every coin that one would even consider dipping is unique. And that's where the problem comes into play. For to learn how to tell whether the coin should first be dipped at all, then how tell how long to dip the coin - that requires a great deal of experience. It is not something you can explain with directions. It is only something that one can learn by trial and error unde rthe supervision of somebody whp already knows. And even then those with the most experience will screw it up at times - because each and every coin is unique. What you did before may not work on this coin.

That is why fully 80% of the raw coins out there are problem coins today. Because somebody wanted to know how to do it.

Not very encouraging odds is it ?

__________________
knowledge ..... share it

Just Carl

Every once in while someone says something that is really, really true.

As to cleaning or dipping a coin. I suggest using a Martini. A Vodka Martini of course. With Anchovy Olives too. Now take the coins, lay them down next to the Martini on a soft cotton cloth, drink the Martini, place the coins back where they were. Consider the job done.

Except for the Olives of course.

Ripley

LOL Good idea Carl... i will get right to it. ) Traci

TomCorona

But there is so much more to it than that for each and every coin that one would even consider dipping is unique. And that's where the problem comes into play. For to learn how to tell whether the coin should first be dipped at all, then how tell how long to dip the coin - that requires a great deal of experience. It is not something you can explain with directions.


The directions on "how to" in here, are certainly guarded, granted, but the directions of "how to" in the real world, can more easily be accessed through multiple credible sources on the web. Then return here and,....disclaimer, disclaimer, disclaimer...
Oversimplify...ridicule...evade by non-discussion or selective discussion....whatever. Bottom line..can be done, and without the years and years of exalted experience continually implied, with a little researching, some intelligence, and a bit of trial and error on some non-critical coins.
LOOK FOR THE INFO PEOPLE..it's out there..maybe not much in here (but where really, you'd think it would be), but it's out there. Posting or asking such questions in here and getting straight forward yes or no answers is almost an exercise in futility. Can it be done?? (answer yes but, only will admit it if cornered by logic) Should it be done? (well...we can help there..absolutely never, ever, ever, or ever...) How it can be done??? (we do not discuss that here, at least directly, and if we must..then, only how WE think YOU ought to do it, not actually HOW to do it like we do...professional...disclaimer...experienced...dis claimer)
The internet is your friend....use it.

desertgem

Tom,

There is something to what you say, but for the most part, I don't think it is a conspiracy as it is the voice of "experience" of "failures", as almost everyone who has dipped a coin, certainly has had failures, where the coin was damages or previous damage was exposed.

There is a difference in knowing how, and doing properly. I know how to remove your appendix with a high chance of survival, but if you let me do it, you are making a severe risk. How many people would you want to see me do it on, before you would feel secure? EZest comes with directions, and as you say there are details on the internet, but it is the practice that raises the success ratio. A background in Chemistry will really help understand what is happening and how to control the process, but it is the combination of knowledge and experience. The information is no secret as you say, and people will do what they want in the privacy of their home, but it doesn't mean that any one has to detail all they know about a subject unless they feel it is constructive and low risk. When we have mentioned acetone, many gives specific instructions to keep people from lighting up a cigar as they do so. That is just common sense.

You always have an interesting viewpoint and I enjoy reading them.

Jim

TomCorona

Jim
Removing an appendix and coin "cleaning" are hardly the same but I get your point. Nothing wrong with experienced collectors giving their opinion. I will forever be learning and appreciate and benefit from them. Lighting a cigar using acetone? Ok...so I guess that's the mentality this forum needs to be geared to put out information? One extreme to the other..neither really an accurate analogy, and I don't know if there really is one. Nothing wrong again, with opinions. I enjoy them, as I do most of yours. I guess I get tired of reading "warning...warning" on all clean posts, perhaps as much as some of the posters get tired of posting the repititive information, and then still really offer anything other than what basically amounts to their opinion. I guess I'll offer an analogy..It's like when you want simple instructions on how to hook up a simple piece of home entertainment equipment...I just want to know how to turn the damn thing on hook it up..not the 80 million "warning electric shock can occur" or, "this unit complies with FCC blah blah blah.." or "watch out for lightning" and "don't rub your feet on the carpet" and on and on and on of continuing paragraphs and sub paragraphs, addendums, of non-relevant information (in 5 different languages). That may not exactly be an accurate analogy either but as with me, I hope you do get the point. I'd rather read a disclaimer saying "We the founders here at the coin forum disagree with any and all assertions that coin cleaning can be accomplished, so we therefore reserve the right to block, badger, ridicule,
edit, discredit, or just plain ignore anything that is different than our opinions. We further state that our opinions are indeed facts". That woulda saved me a lot of time on that particular subject.