Genuine ??

SINED · 07-19-2008, 12:33 PM

I know Wheres George is a touchy subject here on Coin Talk. The site does have an interesting collecters forum. Please don't start complaining about stamping bills. That is not why I started this thread. A user found this web press note and inquired about it's worth and if it was genuine. Only one reply was skeptical and the rest mentioned a four digit worth for the note. It's a beaut if it's genuine. The lone skeptic thought there should be more of the same errors and wondered why they haven't surfaced. So let it fly, real or faked. If it's real what's it worth?

urbanchemist · 07-19-2008, 12:49 PM

well if the bill is authentic really skies could be the limit. the regular bill without this error would be $200 CH CU lets say it was just a star note for that series you are looking at $1400 in CH CU. now if this is a real bill even in the condition it is in with the possibilty of this maybe being an example of only a handful of bills like this you might even be talking in the high 4 maybe 5 figures for its worth. but i dont really think the bill is authentic. it would have popped up somewhere before. maybe lewminator should put in his thought on it. lets see what others have to say

SINED · 07-19-2008, 12:59 PM

I have to add nobody on WG suggested stamping the bill. First was to store it in a safe deposit box. Second to contact several reputable dealers for their opinion. Lastly to submit the bill for grading and authenticity. The owner is a noob but knew they had something special.

urbanchemist · 07-19-2008, 01:10 PM

after looking closer it looks like the star was added. i am no pro with photoshop and i was able to come up with this. i am sure with enough time i could come up with something better. until its been sent into a TPG i am going for a fake

SINED · 07-19-2008, 01:35 PM

Nice PhotoShop job UC, I mean really nice.

A few comments from WG

#1 Yeah, if that's a one-of-a-kind note it's easily going to top four figures. Get it graded. Congrats, what a great find.

#2 For some strange reason a lot of currency dealers don't think webs have any value. Stupid! There are some of the key plate combinations that retail for $3000-$3800 in Unc. condition.

Your beautiful error note should easily bring $3000-5000 and I'd sure offer you that for it if I could afford to do so. Please have it graded by PCGS. An ordinary F--L 2/2 it lists for $75 in XF condition. It's not an F--* but if it were it would list for $850 in XF.

#3 You're not kidding. Looking at the picture, I can't see any signs of a fake, but the error is just too strange to be entirely believable....

#4 This sort of error ought to affect a whole bunch of consecutive bills; if the one suffix wheel was set incorrectly, or got rotated during a press run, then it should've kept on producing bills with the identical error. (Print runs like this are known in several different series, where many thousands of consecutive bills all have the same mismatch. There's a batch of 1957 silver certificates where one serial number is A..A and the other is Q..A, for example.) The fact that nobody's ever heard of this F..*/F..L mismatch before makes me suspect that something's not right here, especially given how well-studied web notes are. No way are there thousands of these out there and this is the first time anybody's noticed.

It's *possible* that somehow the BEP managed to print a very small number of notes like this, but it'd be strange. Therefore you'd definitely want to get this certified by the experts before trying to sell it, since otherwise a fair percentage of the potential bidders would likely be too skeptical to put up their money

**Daggarjon** · 07-22-2008, 09:17 AM

2 things about this note makes me think its a fake image. First, if you zoom into around the star, there is a very faint 'cirlce'. This could be remnants of the planting of the star. Second, the last 7 just before the star, there is faint evidence of freenish ink. This could be a slight smudge from the printing of the serial, but it looks more to me to be a smudge from the removal of the 'L' There are several tools in photoshop that could easily do what looks like was done here. I do hope it is a real note however, and if the person who has this note in hand is NOT some jokester, then he would get this note validated and verfied.

urbanchemist · 07-22-2008, 06:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daggarjon

2 things about this note makes me think its a fake image. First, if you zoom into around the star, there is a very faint 'cirlce'.

thats the first thing i caught. i blew up the picture and you can see a circle. i still would like to see it graded by a TPG to see its authenticity

SINED · 07-22-2008, 10:47 AM

Well thought out reply Daggarjon, UC proved photoshop is a possibility. I can't see the evidence of smudge or erasure on my screen but have no doubt it may be there. I hope it's real and will post any further news on it's authenticity and selling / value.

shortysnana · 07-22-2008, 03:12 PM

I am the holder of the note and a jokester by no means, Have spoken to Bob Kvederas, he first suggested that i sell to the dealer who offered 5000 dollars, I told him that I wanted to send it in for grading and authentication, he said he analyzed the scans and his opinion is that it is real, today another e-mail asking me to keep him informed of my selling of the note if in fact I do decide to do so, and also he would like to put it in his coming new edition of his book. I am waiting for my packet from the certification company so the note can be sent in, until then there is nothing more I can say, when it comes back I will post it.thanks to everyone for their helpful input on this. Just htought I would add my 2 cents after a link to this thread was sent to me.

**Peter T Davis** · 07-22-2008, 03:20 PM

Thanks for joining Coin Talk shortysnana. I think a lot of us will say please do come back and keep us up to date on what happens after you send it in for authentication.

I assume by what you've said your plan is to sell it. Are you going for a private sale or are you considering putting it in a public auction?

shortysnana · 07-22-2008, 03:29 PM

not really sure but have been advised to sell it at auction, not really experienced at all of this so just going to follow the steps and take in all of the good advice

shortysnana · 08-22-2008, 01:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter T Davis

Thanks for joining Coin Talk shortysnana. I think a lot of us will say please do come back and keep us up to date on what happens after you send it in for authentication.

I assume by what you've said your plan is to sell it. Are you going for a private sale or are you considering putting it in a public auction?

The note is up on the Heritage website under Major errors if anyone wants to look...I don't know how to post the link.

**Daggarjon** · 07-22-2008, 04:20 PM

if and/or when (dont mean to sound skeptical, but its my nature lol) the note comes back graded as real, that would be HUGE!! It truly would be an awsome find to the hobby! not to mention your pocket if you are inclined to sell it! just be sure to keep us all up to date

**Daggarjon** · 07-23-2008, 08:42 AM

well urban, not to play the hater for the OP (meaning this comment is only in jest

)

i could take the note, place it in the holder and even make it look real, all using photoshop

I could join the SGS team and give it a grade of MS70 .. err..

Seriously though, i do hope the note turns out to be authentic! What a great find it would be!

Aslanmia · 07-23-2008, 01:58 PM

Okay, I'll take the bullet...

I'm not much of a currency collector, so can someone explain to me why this error is so profound? (I assume the error is the * and L combo on the same note.)

Welcome to Coin Talk! Register Now, it's easy and FREE!