Hobo

Recently I was high bidder on a cheap coin on eBay. The reason I bought it is the coin is a semi-scarce (not rare) variety listed in the Cherrypicker's Guide. The coin is in AG to G condition and would be worth $12 to $15 to a variety collector. I outbid the only other bidder and got the coin for $1.50. Shipping was about double what the coin cost but I was pleased with my purchase. That is I was pleased until I received the coin.

The coin I received is not the coin shown in the auction photos. That coin is from a completely different die than the one I received. Naturally, the coin I received is the common variety and worth about what I paid for it (not counting the shipping).

I e-mailed the seller and told him that I did not receive the coin depicted in the auction and pointed out the difference in dies. I asked him to exchange the coin he shipped me for the one shown in the auction photos or refund my money. I e-mailed him tonight so I haven't gotten a response yet. I don't know if he will be a man of honor or if he will try to cause me grief.

I don't like this kind of deception but I don't want to get in a pi$$ing match over less than $5 or risk getting my first negative feedback by giving him a negative if he refuses to send me the coin I bought. How would you handle this situation?

__________________
No state shall emit bills of credit, make any thing but gold and silver coin a tender in payment of debts, coin money . . . - US Constitution, Article 1, Section 10

ANA LM-3799; OHNS LM-59; SUSCC R-4005. All coins stored in bank safe deposit box.

rlm's cents

My guess is that you are sol. PayPal will not help since you cannot prove that you have not switched the coin or, at best, you will need to prove that it is significantly less valuable. i.e. pay for an appraisal. The only thing I know that you can do is publish his name so the rest of us will not get suckered also.

Daggarjon

paypal will help if the dispute is opened with a grievenace that the item recieved was not as described.

at least, they have for me in the past.

aside from that, this is the risk we take buyingoff Ebay. The seller just might not care, and might already have negative feedbacks for this sort fo thing. If you do leave a negative, and he leaves on as well, post a comment below the feedback you recieved explaning the deal.

as a side note, this is close tot he reason i recieved my only negative. it upset me for weeks, but what else to do besides letting the seller get away with it.

__________________
Please visit My coin and currency Website. Any comments appreciated either on cointalk, or by signing my Guestbook

WINS Member #: 779 - IBNS Member #: 9963

Most coin or currency storage questions answered here

Shortgapbob

Seems like this happens somewhat often with lower priced coins. A seller will use a stock photo of a coin, like a low grade Buffalo Nickel, then sell a few dozen of them.

It makes it difficult for those of us who are variety hunters to buy coins when the sellers use stock photos.

__________________
"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it." -- Aristotle

ANA Member # 1214770
WINS Member #678
EAC Member# 5591
Member: Western Maryland Coin Club

DJCoinz

If he does not respond within a reasonable time frame, or if he does and refuses, I would definitely neg him. Even if he does give you a retaliatory neg, most people will be able to see that it was in fact retaliatory...if you write a good enough neg.

__________________
aka Dan

ACW

Ditto.

Ebay is just getting worse all the time. I am starting to see this same scenario posted over and over. Seller doesn't get what he feels is a good price so he just switches the coin.

__________________
STEVE

NPCoin

Perfect feedback means one of two things:

1) You don't do much traffic on eBay

or

2) You are easily manipulated and pushed over.

Give him the neg with a proper explanation if he does not respond to you in the fashion you desire, and accept any retaliation he may try to give you. But, don't just stop there. Take the extra three steps and begin the process of making his online scamming life ... hard. I have posted a number of times on a number of boards that we have an extensive network of bureaucracies for a reason here in the States.

First, a good thing to do is every time you make a bid, after you confirm your bid, go back to the full listing for the item and print the page to a file. Create a specific directory on your hard drive to hold these files. I number them according to the item number. Keep this file until you are completely satisfied with your item.

I have found a number of times in the past seven years I have dealt with eBay that listings have a habit of changing or outright disappearing when things start to go the legal route, and the printed file (with the URL, Title and date headers) is sound evidence of what your contract actually was with the seller.

If things go sour, especially with bait and switch, there are a few people (bureaucracies) to contact. First, you want to submit a complaint with the regional Postal Inspector's office with an explanation of what transpired and a copy of the listing. Send the same complaint to your State's Attorney General's Consumer Protection division, the State Attorney General's Consumer Protection division of the state the seller resides/locates from, the Federal Trade Commission, and if the item was priced over $1,000 contact the regional FBI for criminal investigation.

It may seem like an overkill, especially for an under $10 item, but this is the real way of stopping these people. As more and more complaints file into these varied agencies, they'll do the math and see how much damage (not just to consumers, but to their tax revenues) these frauds are doing, and will eventually take action.

And if you get taken on a moderately priced item ($1,000+) most definitely file a claim in your Federal Circuit Court and take them for everything you can. For the smaller items, making life miserable for them is enough and takes less than just a few hours to deal with.

__________________
Numismatics is a never ending learning process. And numismatists are the students in this process with time as its teacher.

Troodon

Or 3) are just extremely lucky. (I've been lucky so far;I've only had two people that I've had to leave negative feedback for, one seller and one buyer, and neither retaliated with negative feedback of their own. I'm also not a very high volume eBayer either as a seller or buyer so #2 applies to me as well.)

Too many eBay sellers practically get away with murder because people are in fear of retalitory negative feedback, even when at worst they still have a positive rating in the high 90's. Trust me, no seller or buyer will be turned away by you have a slightly less than perfect rating... those that are concerned will actually READ your negative feedbacks (a radical notion, I know) and realize that your negatives are just retalitory and nothing to be genuinely concerned about. People who are concenred about others' negative feedback don't just look at the raw numbers. People are realistic enough to realize that 100% customer satisfaction for either sellers or buyers is unrealistic if you do high enough volumes of business; there's always somebody you just can't make happy. Don't let unjustificed paranoia about negative feedback prevent you from leaving it for those who truly deserve it.

__________________
"It's a Sacagawea dollar! You can take it to the bank, and trade it in for a real dollar!" -Marge Simpson

My paper money collection- updated constantly!

Arizona Jack

OR, perhaps you do a good job taking pictures, communicate with the seller/buyer, put fairness and integrity into what you do and the way you do it, and avoid scam tactics such as restocking fees, photoshopped pictures and outrageous shipping charges and describe your items honestly?

__________________
W.I.N.S / ANA / SLCC / Mesa Coin Club
I am a poker player ..."thats beyond trailer trash"
Joan Rivers on Celebrity Apprentice, 4/09
Hot Sauce Fanatic !!!

MVC

As a seller, I almost always provide positive feedback to the buyer after I have payment and I ship the item as a sign of good faith to the buyer. I have yet to have a problem with this. I say almost always as I sometimes am not able to get around to it for a few days after my trip to the PO. I do see some sellers state that they will leave positive feedback after positive feedback is left for them. This is the wrong approach

As a buyer, I will and have left negative when needed. It just floors me when people leave a positive feedback yet state in the text of the feedback they were not happy (insert names of MS70 coin sellers here)

__________________
MVC

rotobeast

Take a vacation and show up on the guys doorstep.

coleguy

...or 4) You're a smart and responsible buyer and only buy from trusted sellers with reputable business practices.
Guy~

andy21us

When I buy anything off of ebay I always check out the seller before I bid on a item. Not only checking his or her feedback rating but when he or she gives their feedbacks (before or after the buyer give theirs). A reparable seller will always give his or her feedback before the buyers gives theirs. If the seller always waits after the buyer gives theirs then they are hiding something most of the time.

DJCoinz

FYI, this is a completely untrue statement. Over half of ebay sellers do it and I don't blame them in the least bit.

__________________
aka Dan

andy21us

I stand corrected again. Over half of the ebay sellers have something to hide.

I'm only kidding DJ

I know a lot of the reason why sellers wait to give their feedback but those reason don't make it right to hold a possible neg. feedback over a buyer. If the buyer pays for the item that he or she bids on as the seller has instructed then the seller has the obligation and SHOULD give their feedback at that time and not wait. Inturn the buyer has the same obliation to contact the seller if there is a problem with the item and try to resolve the problem before they give their feedback.

What I was trying to say is that there are a lot of sellers out there that will give their feedback first and those are the ones that will most likey not try to rip you off.