Thread: Rolls from banks, good idea or waste of time?

I have noticed in my days of working at a cash register that there are actually a decent amount of wheat pennies, buffalo nickels, silver nickels, and 1964 and older silver coins that people pass around without noticing. I thought that it may be a good idea to go to the bank and pick up some rolls of pennies, nickels, dimes, etc and look through to see what i can get (who knows it may even be fun ). If i get nothing, i can just bring my change to a different bank and they will give me bills. Is this a good idea or would i just simply be wasting my time?

1. trade your change for more change
2. if nothing else, it is indeed fun
3. check all of your lincolns for errors/varieties
4. good idea!



Jasn

Originally Posted by Simius_Dei

1. trade your change for more change
2. if nothing else, it is indeed fun
3. check all of your lincolns for errors/varieties
4. good idea!



Jasn

When you go through the quantity I do, number 1 is not an option. Even for small quantities, it takes an understanding teller to cooperate (younger kids get away with trading coins for coins easier than an adult).

My preference is to take the coins back to a different bank all together. I try to make sure my coins have to actually go through the federal reserve branch before I can get them back again (this requires requesting boxes at many banks and figuring out which ones use different companies to roll the coins).

Hey Gatzdon,

Just out of curiosity, is it really worth the time, effort and energy?

Lots of us do that all the time. Enjoy!

Yes, alot of us do it, and its tons of fun. Last week I got 20 in nickels, and got a 1939, a 1940, a 1945-S (silver) and a buffalo nickel. Not to mention several from the fifties. Alot of people on this forum get large quantities of half dollars and find silver ones. Welcome to the forum by the way.

Half dollar rolls are definitely the most worthwhile. Since May I've found more than two full rolls of silver.

Cool, so if i were to bring 40 dollars to the bank, let's say, for example, I'd get:

$20 - 1 roll of halves
$10 - 1 roll of quarters
$5 - 1 roll of dimes
$4 - 2 rolls of nickels
$1 - 2 rolls of pennies

Is this a good mix or do you guys think that quarters are too scarce to bother with?

P.S. Thanks for the welcoming!

i've had the most success with nickels, and cents. Ive never found any silver quarters or dimes.

Thank you for the welcome.
Being (mainly) a Darksider living in the U.S.A., I cannot just go to the bank and request a roll of “world“coins. The local branches are too small.
But to buy boxes of coins from a bank, search thru them, re-roll them and bring them to another bank?
No, thinking about it again I can see where it would be fun. Very similar to buying a bulk lot of world coins.

No need to reroll coins, you dump them into the machine that counts them for you.

Originally Posted by JHar4330

No need to reroll coins, you dump them into the machine that counts them for you.

For those of you lucky enough to have those. Some of us aren't that fortunate.

Originally Posted by Topher

For those of you lucky enough to have those. Some of us aren't that fortunate.

My bank has one behind the counter, and they're happy to drop my bags o coins in, free of charge. Usually when I'm roll searching I have a free afternoon anyway though, so I just reroll most of the non-keepers.

Originally Posted by JHar4330

Cool, so if i were to bring 40 dollars to the bank, let's say, for example, I'd get:

$20 - 1 roll of halves
$10 - 1 roll of quarters
$5 - 1 roll of dimes
$4 - 2 rolls of nickels
$1 - 2 rolls of pennies

Is this a good mix or do you guys think that quarters are too scarce to bother with?

P.S. Thanks for the welcoming!

With 40 bucks, I would stick with one denomination. I personally would go with nickels. I think you find more old coins in nickels, because people don't look through them for silver, since they only contained some silver in WW2. I wouldn't bother with dimes and quarters unless your trying to fill an album or folder with 1965 to present coins. If you want to find silver. Take a few hundred bucks and get halves, that is, if you bank has halves. Mine usually only has about $100 in halves. Good luck.

Originally Posted by JHar4330

Cool, so if i were to bring 40 dollars to the bank, let's say, for example, I'd get:

$20 - 1 roll of halves
$10 - 1 roll of quarters
$5 - 1 roll of dimes
$4 - 2 rolls of nickels
$1 - 2 rolls of pennies

Is this a good mix or do you guys think that quarters are too scarce to bother with?

P.S. Thanks for the welcoming!

Most banks do not have a lot of halves on hand. You may have to order a box of them if your bank will do it