Thread: Whats A Fair Price For A 1959-P Franklin NGC MS65

$50+ ?


Numismedia has it at $71.25 but I never go by those prices

$50-$60 is not bad.

Originally Posted by BUncirculated

$50-$60 is not bad.

I picked up (2) for $55

Originally Posted by zachfromnj

I picked up (2) for $55

Shut the front door, no way!

delete post

Originally Posted by jcakcoin

Anywhere in the $45-$55 range for a 65 no FBL, however a 65 FBL would be somewhere between $60-$75

NGC values the 59P MS65 FBL at $171, and the cheapest I've seen those is around $138-$142.50

I've had a great week of ebay snipes

Originally Posted by zachfromnj

I've had a great week of ebay snipes

I'll say you did fantastic getting two for $55.

Originally Posted by BUncirculated

NGC values the 59P MS65 FBL at $171, and the cheapest I've seen those is around $138-$142.50

Oops...I was thinking of the 58P

Originally Posted by zachfromnj

I picked up (2) for $55

Originally Posted by BUncirculated

I'll say you did fantastic getting two for $55.

Yeah the title said "2 Franklins" and I noticed the picture was of slabbed coins so I looked and referenced to numismedia prices and I bought it asap.

Originally Posted by jcakcoin

Oops...I was thinking of the 58P

I was wondering if you had the right date in your head

Originally Posted by zachfromnj

Yeah the title said "2 Franklins" and I noticed the picture was of slabbed coins so I looked and referenced to numismedia prices and I bought it asap.

Either someone got them really really cheap, stole them and was looking for a quick sale, or didn't know what the hack they're doing.

Nice job on the snipe.

Originally Posted by BUncirculated

Either someone got them really really cheap, stole them and was looking for a quick sale, or didn't know what the hack they're doing.

Nice job on the snipe.

Guess I'll keep the other snipes to myself

Originally Posted by zachfromnj

I've had a great week of ebay snipes

I wouldn't tell anyone.

Got any pics or a link to the auction?