Thread: did i get a good deal

2012 SILVER EAGLE S$1 EARLY RELEASES BLUE LABEL NGC MS70 2012 (S) SAN FRANCISCO SILVER EAGLE NGC MS69 EARLY RELEASES $53.95 2012 1 oz. American Silver Eagle NGC MS69 * Early Release $46.00

$69.00

2012(W) SILVER EAGLE STRUCK AT WEST POINT MINT EARLY RELE. total 231.95 i have 2 ms 70's 2 ms 69's all early releases do you think it was worth it???

$63.00

Hmm, I would say, you get them for about what they were worth, so you didn't get a deal, but you didn't get cheated either.

Originally Posted by CoinCollector14

Hmm, I would say, you get them for about what they were worth, so you didn't get a deal, but you didn't get cheated either.

I concur. OP paid average retail.

ive seen people pay 130 bucks for a modern ms 70..

Originally Posted by kaosleeroy108

ive seen people pay 130 bucks for a modern ms 70..

Indeed, I've seen people overpay for a wide variety of objects, not just coins.

Well I know this much there guarnteed to be worth atleast more than what I paid for them by guess... not much but from what I got in my ngc registry it looks like the ms 70 over or bout 100 dollars and the 69s are about 56 dollars

Originally Posted by kaosleeroy108

Well I know this much there guarnteed to be worth atleast more than what I paid for them by guess... not much but from what I got in my ngc registry it looks like the ms 70 over or bout 100 dollars and the 69s are about 56 dollars

Indeed? Who issues this valuable guarantee? I want them to guarantee my coins will be worth more than I paid for them too!

4 ounces of silver for about $58/oz is what you got.

Originally Posted by bsowa1029

4 ounces of silver for about $58/oz is what you got.

Yup, at current silver prices at the time of this writing ($27 an ounce), equals 115% paid over spot. 58 is what percent over 27 = 215%. But the only thing that really matters is, are you happy with the purchase?

I've added a few peices to my ngc registry an they been about right...yea I'm happy but I'm wondering if people have paid more than I have???

You got just about $231 worth of stuff. A great deal at $100, a poor Deal at $250. So you did OK

People do overpay. Most I have overpaid for something though is $5 for foreign coins worth $2. I do believe though I may have underpaid for things. The quarters below I bought when melt was close to $6 and have seen the 1930 standing being priced for $15 which is overcharging.

Why do you care that they are early release? I don't.

That looks to me that it is 2 oz not 4 oz. They are slabbed and graded though. I personally wouldn't by slabbed bullion coins but that is just me and don't know about their value.

Originally Posted by buddy16cat

That looks to me that it is 2 oz not 4 oz. They are slabbed and graded though. I personally wouldn't by slabbed bullion coins but that is just me and don't know about their value.

Where are you getting 2 oz and not 4 oz? The OP purchased 4 2012 ASE coins, I'd say that's 4 oz of silver, not 2 oz.