I'm going to run it by the local collectors at the next club meeting. I too feel funny about it and I don't know ancients but I also have a funny feeling about some of his other offerings. Usually a seller will have all authentic or all fakes, or mostly fakes, and some of the seller's coins bother me. I messaged the seller 2 days ago and not a peep back from him so that too has me on edge.
I may run it by the local coin shop dude and see what he says and if says fake, I'm sending it back and won't wait till the club meeting.
Thanks all!
Ribbit