I had a new idea. Maybe instead of a yearly contest, it would be a monthly contest, with a yearly winner chosen from the 12 monthly winners. The contest would be split into 5 categories, and each person could enter up to 3 coins (or other things found in rolls) in whichever categories they wanted. The categories would be:
Oldest
Most valuable
Coolest in general
Most unusual
Best error/variety
I think it would be fun to enter. Might be too much trouble for someone to take on the task of organizing it all.
P.S., Bigs, maybe your avatar is your roll find.

That would be a winner!