Local coin auction prices paid

[bp0405]

Hello everyone,

I attended a local coin auction a couple of weeks ago and thought I would share with everyone the prices that were paid. The coins were graded by someone not affiliated with the auction (so we were told).

This was their third auction this year and I had a great time. Can't wait until the next one.

Couple of these have no prices. I was to slow or they were to fast moving on to the next coin for me to write down the amount....

1. 1857 Flying Eagle (VF) $25.00
2. 1858 Flying Eagle (VF) $20.00
3. 1848 Large Cent (VF) $30.00
4. 1909 VDB Lincoln Penny (AU) $7.50
5. 1864 Two Cent Piece (AU58) $35.00
6. 1942 Mercury Dime (MS65) $7.50
7. 1944 Mercury Dime (MS65) $7.00
8. 1856 Seated Liberty Quarter (MS61) $90.00
9. 1822 Bust Half (EF) $130.00
10. 1826 Bust Half (EF) $130.00
11. 1839 Bust Half (EF) $100.00
12. 1858 Seated Liberty Half (VF) $40.00
13. 1938 D Walking Liberty Half (AU50) $105.00
14. 1921 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $40.00
15. 1885 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS64) $55.00
16. 1885 O Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $65.00
17. 1885 O Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $65.00
18. 1886 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS64) $60.00
19. 1887 S Morgan Silver Dollar Tor (MS63) $125.00
20. 1889 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $65.00
21. 1898 O Morgan Silver Dollar (MS64) $50.00
22. 1892 S Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $60.00
23. 1901 Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $40.00
24. 1904 S Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $60.00
25. 1921 Morgan Silver Dollar DTF (MS64PL) $80.00
26. 1880 S Morgan Silver Dollar (MS64DMPL) $150.00
27. 1880 O Morgan Silver Dollar (MS62) $70.00
28. 1882 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $40.00
29. 1883 O Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $35.00
30. 1883 S Morgan Silver Dollar (AU58) $100.00
31. 1884 O Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $35.00
32. 1885 O Morgan Silver Dollar (MS64) $75.00
33. 1885 S Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $35.00
34. 1886 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS64) $50.00
35. 1887 S Morgan Silver Dollar Tor (MS63) $70.00
36. 1888 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS62) $45.00
37. 1889 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $35.00
38. 1889 O Morgan Silver Dollar (AU55) $50.00
39. 1890 S Morgan Silver Dollar TOR (MS63) $75.00
40. 1890 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $40.00
41. 1891 S Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63DMPL) $100.00
42. 1892 O Morgan silver Dollar (AU50) $50.00
43. 1892 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS60) $100.00
44. 1892 S Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $50.00
45. 1896 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS62)
46. 1898 O Morgan Silver Dollar (MS62) $45.00
47. 1898 O Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $50.00
48. 1899 S Morgan Silver Dollar (F) $35.00
49. 1899 O Morgan Silver Dollar (MS60) $50.00
50. 1901 Morgan Silver Dollar (AU50) $130.00
51. 1901 S Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $55.00
52. 1903 S Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $90.00
53. 1904 S Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $80.00
54. 1921 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $60.00
55. 1924 S Peace Silver Dollar (MS62) $90.00
56. 1884 S Morgan Silver Dollar (MS62) $200.00
57. 1886 S Morgan Silver Dollar (MS62) $200.00
58. 1887 S Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $100.00
59. 1888 S Morgan Silver Dollar (AU58) $120.00
60. 1889 CC Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $650.00
61. 1890 CC Morgan Silver Dollar (AU50) $100.00
62. 1893 O Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $100.00
63. 1893 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $475.00
64. 1893 O Morgan Silver Dollar (VF) $100.00
65. 1895 O Morgan Silver Dollar (AU50) $350.00
66. 1895 S Morgan Silver Dollar (EF) $450.00
67. 1894 Morgan Silver Dollar (MS63) $340.00
68. 1921 Peace Silver Dollar (MS62) $130.00
69. 1853 2 ½ Dollar Gold Piece (UNC) $350.00
70. 1914 2 ½ Dollar Gold Piece (UNC) $500.00
71. 1915 2 ½ Dollar Gold Piece (UNC) $425.00
72. 1900 5 Dollar Gold Piece (MS63) $450.00
73. Benjamin Franklin Collection (MS63) $45.00
74. 1890 CC Morgan Dollar $75.00
75. 1826 Bust Half Dollar $55.00
76. 1878 S Morgan Dollar (MS63) $50.00
77. 1879 S Morgan Dollar (MS64) $65.00
78. 1897 O Morgan Dollar (AU55) $40.00
79. 1885 O Morgan Dollar (MS64) $55.00
80. 1882 S Morgan Dollar (MS64)
81. 1897 S Morgan Dollar (MS64) $70.00
82. 1842 Large US Cent $20.00
83. 1849 Large US Cent $12.50
84. 1849 Large US Cent $15.00
85. 1857 Flying Eagle (XF) $40.00
86. 1858 Flying Eagle (VF/XF) $30.00
87. 1876 Indianhead Cent (XF/AU) $100.00
88. 1853 Three (3) Cent Silver $20.00
89. 1829 Bust Half Dime (VX/XF) $50.00
90. 1831 Bust Half Dime (VG) $20.00
91. 1854 Seated Half Dollar (VF/XF) $50.00
92. 1858 O Seated Half Dollar (XF) $50.00
93. 1859 O Seated Half Dollar (F) $35.00
94. 1921 Mercury Dime (Key Coin) $45.00
95. 1925 Stone Mountain Com. Half Dollar (BUT) $60.00
96. Five (5) Walking Liberty Half Dollar Coins: 1938, 1941,1942, 1943 and 1947-D $60.00
97. 1921 Peace Dollar Key Coin (XF) $90.00
98. 1922 Peace Dollar (MS65) $50.00
99. 1922 D Peace Dollar (MS62) $45.00
100. 1923 Peace Dollar (MS60) $25.00
101. 1923 D Peace Dollar (MS62) $40.00
102. 1924 Peace Dollar (MS64) $40.00
103. 1925 Peace Dollar (MS65) $70.00
104. 1926 S Peace Dollar (MS60) $50.00
105. 1927 D Peace Dollar (XF) $35.00
106. 1934 D Peace Dollar (VF) $45.00
107. 1878 S Morgan Dollar (MS63 PL) $50.00
108. 1880 Morgan Dollar (MS61) $35.00
109. 1884 Morgan Dollar (MS63 PL) $45.00
110. 1885 Morgan Dollar (MS63) $45.00
111. 1885 O Morgan Dollar (MS63) $45.00
112. 1886 Morgan Dollar (MS64) $30.00
113. 1887 Morgan Dollar (MS64 PL) $40.00
114. 1889 Morgan Dollar (MS60) $30.00
115. 1890 Morgan Dollar (MS61) $35.00
116. 1890 S Morgan Dollar (MS60) $35.00
117. 1896 Morgan Dollar (MS62) $25.00
118. 1898 Morgan Dollar (MS64) $35.00
119. 1899 O Morgan Dollar (MS64 PL) $45.00
120. 1900 Morgan Dollar (MS63) $45.00
121. 1900 O Morgan Dollar (MS64 PL) $40.00
122. 1904 O Morgan Dollar (MS64 PL) $45.00
123. 1921 Morgan Dollar (MS61) $40.00

[mark_h]

I would like to see some pictures of the coins to see if the grading was close. A few of the prices look reasonable, but only if the grade was as posted.

[Hobo]

Originally Posted by bp0405

19. 1887 S Morgan Silver Dollar Tor (MS63) $125.00

95. 1925 Stone Mountain Com. Half Dollar (BUT) $60.00

I'm curious. What is "Tor"? (Toned original?) What is "BUT"? (Brilliant Uncirculated Toned?)

[mark_h]

How about Brilliant Uncirculated Toned?

[bp0405]

Here is #91 the 1854 Seated Half. They had it graded as VF/XF. Also #110 a 1885 Morgan that was graded MS63. These were the only ones I was able to buy. The Seated Half is my first. Think I overpaid just a bit but I do like the coin.

#15 (no picture) was also a 1885 Morgan graded as MS64 that sold for $55. Comparing #15 and #110 before the auction I thought that #110 was a much nicer coin.

[ctrl]

Nice coins, but is that 1854 Seated Half really VF/XF?

[Aslanmia]

I think it's a push to make that half an F, let alone XF.. there's almost no facial features left.

[mark_h]

Originally Posted by ctrl

Nice coins, but is that 1854 Seated Half really VF/XF?

I do not think is XF - I think F maybe at best VF. Not an expert on those. As for overpaying - if you are happy with the coins then you did not overpay. I think the Morgan grade is pretty accurate - it looks like it is in the 63 range. Nice coins by the way. I like seated coinage also, but I do not have any halves yet.

[Doug21]

Originally Posted by Aslanmia

I think it's a push to make that half an F, let alone XF.. there's almost no facial features left.

agree, the grading is loose. I don't see a full Liberty on the half, which you kinda sorta need for a Fine ( or at least used to), so F-12 is a stretch,IMO.

This sounds awfully cheap:

8. 1856 Seated Liberty Quarter (MS61) $90.00

[stevendaniels]

Well whoever bought the 1894 morgan got a pretty good deal!

[Isaiah]

Originally Posted by bp0405

Here is #91 the 1854 Seated Half. They had it graded as VF/XF. Also #110 a 1885 Morgan that was graded MS63. These were the only ones I was able to buy. The Seated Half is my first. Think I overpaid just a bit but I do like the coin.

#15 (no picture) was also a 1885 Morgan graded as MS64 that sold for $55. Comparing #15 and #110 before the auction I thought that #110 was a much nicer coin.

that seated liberty half dollar is HORRIBLY overgraded. It is a very weak FINE. Sorry.